Is it a good diamond for engagement ring?

[JXE]

Someone commented that it is a little bit shallow crown and this cutting may lead to more brightness but less fiery.
Any advices? It got a 0.7 in HCA scores.

 

[MissGotRocks]

No, I would definitely pass on this stone.

 

[JXE]

No, I would definitely pass on this stone.

may i know about the reasons about why?

 

[MissGotRocks]

The crown is shallow and so is the overall depth at 59.6. Without images of the diamond, I would pass.

 

[JXE]

According to below images, it seems that it is ideal case, but there is rounding in GIA report.

OctoNus : Master Stone Set - AGS GOLD 2008 & AGSPGS 1.1.2 November 2007

That's why i need to have a look on this diamond?

 

[MissGotRocks]

That chart does not take in the 59.6 depth. The crown angle is only 14%.
Is the seller providing you with any images?

 

[lovedogs]

I wouldn't buy this if I were you

 

[JXE]

I wouldn't buy this if I were you

I went to have a look for this diamond yesterday, and i learned that it had a little bit less brilliance than other diamonds provided by shop. However, I didn't have any idea about the fiery of it since I could not notice the difference comparing to other diamonds.