shape
carat
color
clarity

Not sure WHAT is happening here....

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

sandia_rose

Shiny_Rock
Joined
Nov 20, 2007
Messages
314
This is a a horrible post for the day after Valentine''s Day, but I am very upset and am hoping that you ladies can put this into perspective for me....sorry in advance if this is long, but I want to give you as much detail as possible about what happened.

Neither my BF nor I are Valentine''s Day people (we think it''s an overblown Hallmark holiday), and given our tense relationship lately, I wasn''t expecting much out of the day. If you remember, we had "the talk" about 2 weeks ago, and I''ve been deliberately lying low. I was in work when he called me. He usually calls me around lunchtime, just to talk, because it breaks up the monotony of the day. When the phone rang, I thought it was either going to be his typical lighthearted chatter, or him asking me if I wanted to go out to dinner after work. Nope.

When I picked up the phone, he asked me what I was doing, and I said, "Working. Someone just left my office and I am trying to wrap my brain around the project they left me with. Why?" And he said, "I know you don''t like Valentine''s Day so I don''t really know what to do here." So I said, "Whatever you want. I don''t have any expectations." And there was this long pause and he said, "I''m just not feeling it." So I said, "Feeling what?" And he said, "This. I don''t know....I was doing a lot of thinking....and I feel like an @ss4ole. You''re an awesome woman. If I look at, I don''t know what you want to call it...your track record?.....you''re incredible. But there''s no fireworks going off that are telling me that you''re positively, absolutely the one for me."

Ladies, as you know, I''ve been sick all week with a bad cold. THAT was NOT what I expected him to say AT ALL. And not yesterday.
38.gif
And I don''t know if it''s my cold or the lack of sleep from my cold or what, but the following came out of my mouth (not sure where it came from...I really don''t):

"What the #$^& planet have you been living on? This is not the #$^& movies. Love doesn''t offer fireworks and little birdies. It''s a lot more subtle than that. This is real life and we are not kids. Do you mean to tell me that it took you a year and a half to come to the realization that I am not for you...after our lives have gotten entwined to this point? As far as I''m concerned, you don''t see ME and never have. Everything you see when you see me is colored by your ex-wife. And that''s not fair."

All he could say in response was, "Maybe." Then he started crying and I said, "Are you home right now?" He was. I told my boss I was not feeling well and went over to his house.

I walked in and the first thing I said was, "Tell me you don''t love me anymore and don''t want to see me anymore." And he said, "But I can''t do that." So I said, "So what is it?" And he said, "I don''t know....I just don''t see a future here." And I said, "Do you think that or feel that?" And he said, "What''s the difference?" And I said, "If you really felt that, you would have just broken up with me." And he said, "I''m just....so....confused." We talked a lot about fear and things in our pasts that make us afraid of relationship stuff, etc. I told him, "In a lot of respects, love is a choice. I chose to love you and stick it out, in spite of all the problems that have gone down." Lots of tears and talking. And then he said, "You know, I had a thought I was thinking about. I have thought about putting an addition on the house to make room for you and P [my son]. Would you consider moving in with me for a month to see how it goes with us day to day, all the time? That way, we''d know for sure if moving forward is the right thing." And I said, "Sure." We are supposed to go on a trip at the end of the month, and we talked about the timeline for this starting when we come back. Fine with me. I should point out that my son splits the time with his father, so any time I have him, we would be at my house, per usual.

After a while, we looked over at the clock and he said, "I don''t want to cut this short, but we only have a couple of hours left of daylight, and I need to look at the lights on my trailor [he has a show to do tonight and the lights on his band trailer have been broken...and he got ticketed last time on them]." So I said, "Well, I''m going to go home and take a nap. Then he said, "Thank you for putting my dumb head on straight. Can I take you for dinner later?" I said, "Sure," and he said he''d call me when he was finished messing with the trailer lights and was on his way to get me. Then I asked him what his daughter was doing (she hadn''t come home from school yet); he told me his ex was taking her for a Valentine dinner around 6 and she''d be out for a couple hours, so he had time to come and get me and go somewhere.

Went home, napped and took a bath. I was feeling fine with the resolution we came up with. The phone rang @ 6:30 while I was in the tub. It was my BF. The first thing he said was, "I lost track of time." And I said, "What?" He said, "While I was under the trailer, Ray (a friend of his) stopped by and has been helping me with the electrical." I could clearly hear Ray in the background. Then he said, "I don''t know what you want to do. D (his daughter) is supposed to be back here at 8. The soonest I can get going is an hour from now." So I said, "Well, I''d thought you were coming to get me. Couldn''t you have called me earlier?" And he said, "I lost track of time and Ray drove by, saw me under the trailer, stopped by to see, and when he saw it was an electrical issue (Ray is an electrician), offered to help me."

After this, I felt deflated. It was like the earlier conversation meant nothing and he was trying to blow me off -- and I said so. He said, "Look. I already feel like an @ss4ole. I can call someone to watch D when she comes back...or you can come down here." And I said, "I don''t want to go all the way down there just to turn around and come back home." So he said, "If you feel comfortable, you can bring a bag and I can go out and get us dinner and we can eat in." I told him, "Fine." The last thing he said was, "I really am trying. I am sorry about the trailer. It''s one thing after another today."

I went down to his house and he wasn''t there but his daughter was. I asked her where he went and she said, "He went to get dinner and will be back in a second." Which he was. He had gone to this Italian place we like and bought calzones and also had bought me a dozen yellow roses.

It was his daughter''s bedtime anyway, and she went to bed while we ate dinner. By the time we finished, it was 10P. I was still feeling my cold, so I got a glass of TheraFlu and we lay in bed watching TV. We started dozing off and turned off the light. We didn''t sleep. Either he kept waking up or I kept waking up. It was uncomfortable. And again, I have no idea where this came from, but I said:

"I was wrong."

He said, "What?" And I said, "I was wrong to try to talk you into staying with me if you don''t want to. I don''t want you to try the month-living-together thing for the sake of me. I am going to go back to sleep and just leave in the morning, OK? I am sorry you''re afraid and I''m sorry I couldn''t make you see that I am not your ex-wife, so....." He said, "Now you''re going in circles and I have a headache and feel like I''m going to get sick." I shut up and we fell asleep at some point.

Alarm goes off at 7A and he''s holding me tight - like he was going to crush my ribs. I still felt like sh*t. I sat up in bed and he tried to pull me back under the covers with him, and I said, "I don''t want to lie back down again....I have to get up and go to work." And then I started crying. Sobby crying like I never do. He whispered, "What?" And I said, "Tell me honestly - not just what you think I want to hear. Do you really want to try the month thing because you want to, or because you somehow feel bad for me?" And he started crying and said, "Because I really, truly want to know. And you know what''s effed up? I lied here last night, trying to imagine what my life would look like without you in it, and there was a big hole in it." And I said, "I''ve done the same and saw the same and it sucks. Not to mention, my son loves you and it would break my heart again to have to tell him we''re not together anymore."

I took a shower and left for work. He told me what I had on looked beautiful. He hugged and kissed me much tenderly than usual. I asked him if he wanted me to go to the show tonight (band playing at club) and he said, "If you want to." So I said, "OK. I guess I''ll leave my stuff here then and just change after work."

Ladies, if this man was a jerk, I would have walked in a second. In my heart, I don''t feel right about walking -- like it''s not the right time. Just thinking about breaking it off with him makes me sick. I really don''t know where I stand with him right now. I want to assume that a) everything is really OK and b) that we''re going to try the month-together experiment. But I need clarification on what really happened here. Part of me is wondering if I feel "insecure" because of how this went down....or if there is a better reason I am not seeing.

Bridget in Connecticut.
 
Yikes. I don''t want to offend, but I think he was trying to really be honest with you about his feelings and you kind of railroaded him (by saying...love is a choice, etc) and now he feels like he has to try. I think you need to let him go...find someone who is SURE about you without having to be convinced. I''m sorry.
 
I feel the opposite. I think you were just expressing your frustration and I think you did it in a pretty mature way. You were able to look back on the conversation, realize where you made a mistake (in making him feel guilty) and you admitted it. Guys are not subtle creatures. They need things in black and white. I think he''s telling you he just needs more time to figure things out. It sounds like you both have history outside of the relationship and I think it''s harder for someone (a guy in particular) to fall in love again and be confident in his feelings when a previous marriage or serious relationship has failed. So give him credit where credit is due, he was honest with you, and be patient with him.
 
Sandia, I was wondering what was doing on...I was thinking about you yesterday, and realized that I hadn''t seen many posts from you in the past few days.

After reading this my initial thought is that you shouldn''t break it off completely from him. I think that he''s totally afraid of commitment because of his ex. Correction: I know he''s afraid of commitment because of his ex. I think that he truly loves you and you do him. I think that when you''ve both tried to look at your lives without each other in it, and seen holes, I really think that that shows you how you both really feel. Perhaps you could try a trial separation and see how it makes you feel. And then if you still want to work things out, try the living together thing.

You have to remember when you have a cold or any illness, EVERYTHING seems worse. And everyone has rough spots too. I don''t think any one of us on this board could stand up and say, "Everything with us has always been absolutely PERFECT." and truly mean it, unless they''re in denial.

I think that if I were in your situation I''d probably step back completely for a few days and give him some time to think about it. I''m not sure that trying to live together is really the route you guys want to take because it doesn''t really allow him to see what it''d be like if you weren''t there. You know what I''m saying? Right now he''s not sure if he wants to spend the rest of his life with you, and the only way for him to figure it out is to see what life is like without you in it.

Right now is reality time. It''s make it or break it time. I think in the long run you guys will make it, and you said yourself that you feel like it''s not time to end it yet. I agree. I don''t think it''s time either, but right now isn''t the time to sit by idly and watch the relationship go where it may. Of course, there is always the chance that he''s just not meant to be with you, but I hope that''s not the case.

I''m sorry you''re going through this Sandia, I wish I could wave a magical wand and make everyone''s lives on here exactly what they want, but it''s just not possible.
38.gif


I feel like I was talking in circles a bit, but I hope that something I said clicked...
 
Oh gosh Sandia,

This could really go either way I think. I'm probably seeing more negatives than positives though. Sorry, probably not what you'd like to hear - and of course this is based only on what you have written and it is easy to get the emphasis wrong on written things.

I'm not sure if you'd be better trying to live together for a month or live without each other for a month. If it were me, I'd probably go for a month's break and then see how we both felt.

Whichever, you need to know exactly where you are with this relationship - if not for yourself, for the sake of your son - which means you need to handle the month together very carefully (which I'm 100% sure you know!).

On the upside, you have been able to both take some time to communicate on this issue and that is positive.

On the downside, I have been in a relationship where I did want out, but just couldn't say it face to face and just ended up crying and feeling bad. I too swore that I was giving it another try because I wanted to - when it was really that I didn't like to see him hurt (which is the worst thing to do). I even arranged for us to go on holiday together to see if I felt differently away from our normal life, routines and friends. It took a forced separation (due to illness) for me to be able to finally call it a day. You need to be sure that both of you want to be together for the right positive reasons and not because you feel upset seeing the other upset or find the idea of being alone traumatic.


Not sure if any of this makes any sense... I think you need to tread carefully and hope for the best. I think you acted the right way in how you reacted though.
 
I know exactly how you feel right now, ugh, it''s so tough.

While I was in limbo I was on a forum devoted to women who were with men who had cold feet. Some just had slightly cold feet and some were full-blown commitmentphobes. The most common thread between all of these men is what your boyfriend is saying: there''s no way to know you''re "the one", there are no big fireworks, they feel like something should be telling them "this is IT!" when the right one comes along. It''s the most common sign of cold feet.

I know you want to give it 150%--you don''t want to walk out because you know he loves you and you obviously love him. But as we all know, love ain''t enough. He has some issues to conquer on his own. And it really, truly is ON HIS OWN. I use the term "walk through the flames" because that''s how it feels. Nothing you say or do can help him realize he wants to spend his life with you, he has to walk through those flames on his own. You can''t hold his hand through it.

If you want to give it more time, then give it more time. If you feel it''s your time to walk away, then do that. Whatever feels right for YOU is what''s most important right now--we''re just here for your support no matter what.
 
I was thinking about you, too, wondering why I haven''t seen you on here...

I''m sorry for you having to go through that, especially when you''re not feeling well. Although I am younger than you, Jer and I had that problem about 5 years ago, where I wasn''t sure, I didn''t feel happy in the relationship - and I thought it was over. We were just stuck in one place, but it wasn''t comfortable being there. We broke up - for all of two weeks - and then realized that working through the issues we had was a lot easier than trying to work through life without each other. I would say to take a little break and then re-evaluate when you''re both ready, if you feel that''s necessary. You seem like an awesome woman, and it doesn''t seem like you''d stay if you didn''t feel like you''re being treated fairly, because of the past you have with the ex. Not every relationship is a perfect 50/50 - but finding that compromise is what makes it work. You have to do what''s best for you - and your son, and I know you''ll make the right decision.

But in the meantime, big hugs for you...
 
Bridgett,

Big hugs to yo!!! I''m so sorry.

It sounds to me like this man needs some time to miss you and get in touch with his true feelings for you. I do not thinking that moving in is the right move right now. If anything, you should be creating distance rather than closing the gap.
 
I think you need a bit more time to process everything that''s gone on, honey. It''s all still crashing around inside your head--once it settles, I think you should go with what your gut tells you is best for you right now. *hugs*
 
I know I''m new here, and this is very bold of me, so please feel free to tell me to go get stuffed......


Or, maybe it''s good that I''m new, maybe it gives me a more detached perspective. Either way, if I overstep my bounds, please tell me to eff off. I looked up some of your previous posts so I''d have a sense of the history of your story, and so I''ve come up with this post.

Some background: I''m not that young (I''ll be 34 in a few weeks). I''ve never been married. I''m currently engaged to a guy who is 42 and has never been married (neither of us have kids). So I''m pretty much in your age range, and my FI definitely is (apropos of nothing, just giving you some background so you can decide whether my advice is coming from an informed place or if I just have no clue).

It is with great respect that I must say I feel this guy has no intention of marrying you. If he wanted to be married, he would be. It''s that simple. Since he has continued to bring up the ex-wife issue, I am getting the feeling that he may have a hard time trusting his own judgement with regards to getting married. Remember, at one point, he was head-over-heels in love with her enough to marry her and create a family with her. He was THAT certain of her, and he turned out to be wrong. That MUSt put a dent in his confidence with regards to choosing a mate.

I am sorry to say, but you could be the most perfect woman on eart, and you will still be judged by the yardstick of his marital trauma. All women in his life will be judged this way. It is called "Emotional Baggage" and only when he faces the issue head-on will this ever be resolved. At this point, it is my very humble and unprofessional opinion that he needs therapy, because his baggage has hurt an exceptional and wonderful woman(that would be you).

He cannot give you what you need because he is not whole. And that is HIS problem, nothing you do can change that, and at this point, you are wasting your time. If it is marriage you want, it is time to move on, because he is not capable of giving you a marriage. Period.

It''s my sincere belief that he tried to break up with you when he said he wasn''t feeling it. Because you reacted so strongly (left your job and ran over there) he took that as a sign that he (and the relationship) are the center of your world, and that he would really hurt you if he left. So he backed down and stayed with you. He is not in this relationship because he loves you, he is in this relationship because he cannot bear the thought of causing you pain, and because your generosity in the relationship makes it very easy for him to stay.

Over the years, you have shown him, with your actions, that he can get the very best you have to offer without having to up the level of commitment. You told him earlier in the relationship, that you wouldn''t date beyond a certain time period without an engagement, a commitment to be married. You told him that you don''t want to be "Eternal Girlfriend" and you told him that you are not a serial monogamist.

He has made no move to propose. He is not excited by the prospect of marrying you. He is not thrilled with the progress of the relationship, and he isn''t eagerly looking forward to becoming your husband. His actions are supplying the answers you need in order to make a decision.

As I have said, my fiance is 42. Same age as you guys. He dated a woman for 5 years before we got together. Around year 3, the woman naturally began to wonder what the future held for the two of them. He knew he didn''t want to marry her, but he stayed because she made his life extremely comfortable, and because he didn''t want to hurt this wonderful girl who loved him. It took two more years of back-and-forth, and her setting (and ignoring) her own ultimatums before he finally broke up with her for good. The sad thing is, she did all that wonderful stuff to prove what a great, wonderful, patient wife she would have made (and she would have) but it made him feel smothered and panicky, like he couldn''t get rid of someone so nice without being a complete jerk. Her excellent treatment of him did the exact OPPOSITE of what she had intended.

Now, I''m not saying to be a mean, cold beee-yotch, or to be manipulative. I''m saying that, no amount of love or good treatment on your part will ever make him want to marry you if he doesn''t already. It only makes him feel too guilty to break up with you, which in turn wastes more of your time, and breaks more of your heart.


When I got together with my fiance it was Thanksgiving of 2006. We were engaged by Christmas time 2007. I am not any better than his former girlfriend, who waited 5 years for a proposal that never happened. He justed wanted to marry me, and didn''t want to marry her. It''s that simple, there''s no mystery as to why. If it''s not meant to be, no amount of wishing and hoping, and being the great girlfriend will make it happen.


A relationship does not have to be bad to be wrong.


If you want to be married, I would (humbly) suggest that you cut your losses and move on from this man, in order not to waste any more time. You''re not compatible as a couple because you do not have the same goal of a shared future.. If you love him, and want to build a life with him, then I would suggest that you find a way to make peace with being his girlfriend, and nothing more.

Personally, I think you deserve better than girlfriend status. And personally, I think there''s a man out there who will snap you right up like the treasure you are, and NEVER let you go.
 
Date: 2/15/2008 1:55:54 PM
Author: Mediterranean
I know I''m new here, and this is very bold of me, so please feel free to tell me to go get stuffed......


Or, maybe it''s good that I''m new, maybe it gives me a more detached perspective. Either way, if I overstep my bounds, please tell me to eff off. I looked up some of your previous posts so I''d have a sense of the history of your story, and so I''ve come up with this post.

Some background: I''m not that young (I''ll be 34 in a few weeks). I''ve never been married. I''m currently engaged to a guy who is 42 and has never been married (neither of us have kids). So I''m pretty much in your age range, and my FI definitely is (apropos of nothing, just giving you some background so you can decide whether my advice is coming from an informed place or if I just have no clue).

It is with great respect that I must say I feel this guy has no intention of marrying you. If he wanted to be married, he would be. It''s that simple. Since he has continued to bring up the ex-wife issue, I am getting the feeling that he may have a hard time trusting his own judgement with regards to getting married. Remember, at one point, he was head-over-heels in love with her enough to marry her and create a family with her. He was THAT certain of her, and he turned out to be wrong. That MUSt put a dent in his confidence with regards to choosing a mate.

I am sorry to say, but you could be the most perfect woman on eart, and you will still be judged by the yardstick of his marital trauma. All women in his life will be judged this way. It is called ''Emotional Baggage'' and only when he faces the issue head-on will this ever be resolved. At this point, it is my very humble and unprofessional opinion that he needs therapy, because his baggage has hurt an exceptional and wonderful woman(that would be you).

He cannot give you what you need because he is not whole. And that is HIS problem, nothing you do can change that, and at this point, you are wasting your time. If it is marriage you want, it is time to move on, because he is not capable of giving you a marriage. Period.

It''s my sincere belief that he tried to break up with you when he said he wasn''t feeling it. Because you reacted so strongly (left your job and ran over there) he took that as a sign that he (and the relationship) are the center of your world, and that he would really hurt you if he left. So he backed down and stayed with you. He is not in this relationship because he loves you, he is in this relationship because he cannot bear the thought of causing you pain, and because your generosity in the relationship makes it very easy for him to stay.

Over the years, you have shown him, with your actions, that he can get the very best you have to offer without having to up the level of commitment. You told him earlier in the relationship, that you wouldn''t date beyond a certain time period without an engagement, a commitment to be married. You told him that you don''t want to be ''Eternal Girlfriend'' and you told him that you are not a serial monogamist.

He has made no move to propose. He is not excited by the prospect of marrying you. He is not thrilled with the progress of the relationship, and he isn''t eagerly looking forward to becoming your husband. His actions are supplying the answers you need in order to make a decision.

As I have said, my fiance is 42. Same age as you guys. He dated a woman for 5 years before we got together. Around year 3, the woman naturally began to wonder what the future held for the two of them. He knew he didn''t want to marry her, but he stayed because she made his life extremely comfortable, and because he didn''t want to hurt this wonderful girl who loved him. It took two more years of back-and-forth, and her setting (and ignoring) her own ultimatums before he finally broke up with her for good. The sad thing is, she did all that wonderful stuff to prove what a great, wonderful, patient wife she would have made (and she would have) but it made him feel smothered and panicky, like he couldn''t get rid of someone so nice without being a complete jerk. Her excellent treatment of him did the exact OPPOSITE of what she had intended.

Now, I''m not saying to be a mean, cold beee-yotch, or to be manipulative. I''m saying that, no amount of love or good treatment on your part will ever make him want to marry you if he doesn''t already. It only makes him feel too guilty to break up with you, which in turn wastes more of your time, and breaks more of your heart.


When I got together with my fiance it was Thanksgiving of 2006. We were engaged by Christmas time 2007. I am not any better than his former girlfriend, who waited 5 years for a proposal that never happened. He justed wanted to marry me, and didn''t want to marry her. It''s that simple, there''s no mystery as to why. If it''s not meant to be, no amount of wishing and hoping, and being the great girlfriend will make it happen.


A relationship does not have to be bad to be wrong.


If you want to be married, I would (humbly) suggest that you cut your losses and move on from this man, in order not to waste any more time. You''re not compatible as a couple because you do not have the same goal of a shared future.. If you love him, and want to build a life with him, then I would suggest that you find a way to make peace with being his girlfriend, and nothing more.

Personally, I think you deserve better than girlfriend status. And personally, I think there''s a man out there who will snap you right up like the treasure you are, and NEVER let you go.

Bridget:

Please read and reread this advice. No one could say it better than she has.

I''m sorry; but I have to agree that this is going nowhere for you.
 
One thing Mediterranean said really stuck out at me. You are a TREASURE. It is clear from your posts here that you are a thoughtful, kind, intelligent, and articulate woman. And honestly...it''s a rare thing. You have a beautiful son, a head that is obviously screwed on right, and in a situation like this, you have acted with dignity where most people would have lost it. Honestly...on VALENTINE''S day, over the phone, while you were at work?? Could he have picked a worse time?

I''m not going to tell you to run for the hills, because you obviously love this man, and he obviously has some very strong feelings for you. But I just don''t see how living together for a month would change anything. What is his reasoning? And what about your son? If it doesn''t work out, wouldn''t this just upset him further?

I do agree that this is HIS issue, and as much as you''d like to be there for him, he needs to work it out on his own. He needs to figure out what is important to him, and whether YOU are important to him.

If I were you, I''d back off, hard as it is. You two have been together long enough, and he''s had more than enough chances to get HIS head screwed on right.

If he makes up his mind that he wants you, he knows where to find you.
 
Oh Sandia I''m so sorry that had to happen to you yesterday! I don''t think what you did was wrong at all and you are exactly right- this isn''t the movies. There are no fireworks, everything is not "perfect" all the time. Relationships take so much work and he has to be willing to make it work. My heart is with you though this time. **HUGS**
 
That has got to be the most insanely accurate and fabulously written piece of advice ever written for the LIW forum.
Where did you come from Med? And teach me more!!!

Instead of running to his house and agreeing to spend the night and go to his band's performances, (which can be perceived as needy and clinging) I think you should be staying away. Show him exactly what it means for you to be out of his life. Not for three or four days, but for three or four weeks.

Let him feel it. If he calls you be candid and short. This will either affirm how he feels or have him come running towards you with a goal.
 
Yeah I''m going to agree with Starset. Fabulous writing and advice Med. I keep thinking about it and I''m thinking that maybe you''re right. I think that most guys know within 6 months if they want to marry a woman, and it doesn''t sound like he is 100% certain that he does... or even 75%. Really, I think at least a trial separation is in order...
 
From inside the situation, the *details* always seem important. The nuances, the tightness of a hug etc. From the outside, its the big picture that matters. The giant glaring uncomfortable facts.

After two years of dating, he tried to break up with you
ON THE PHONE,
WHILE YOU WERE AT WORK,
ON VALENTINE''S DAY ...
and the way he expressed it was
the uber-jerky "I''m not FEELIN IT"

You''re smart. You want to intellectualize the problem. You want to psychoanalyze him into pulling his weight & wanting what you want. But, he''s "not feelin it". And he won''t know how much he wants you, or how much a mistake it is to lose you UNTIL HE DOES.

Just my opinion. But I''m married to a guy I walked away from (and I won''t say I didn''t try a little bargaining before we broke up) .. and he returned six months later with a WHOLE new attitude. Of course, I''ve broken up with people who never showed back up again either. But I tend to think those were for the best.
2.gif


Sorry you''re hurting!
7.gif
 
More background: I have a cousin who strings women along, and it kind of burns me that he introduces girls to the family and they get their hopes up and then he breaks their hearts (often after they''ve invested YEARS in a relationship with his indecisive self!)
38.gif



Sandia Rose, as food for thought, ask yourself what would have happened if you had given a different answer when he said he had been doing some thinking, and he "wasn''t feelin it" and there were "no fireworks" What would have happened if you had said, in a totally even, pleasant tone of voice:

"Oh, I completely understand. I''m sorry you feel that way, but I know you gave it your best shot, and I wish you the best. It would have been great if it worked out, but these things happen. Good luck with the band and stuff......"

If you gave him that "easy out" what do you think he''d have done (in your heart of hearts, I mean. You obviously don''t need to answer here)?

You can''t hold up both ends of the bridge, babe. You''re only obligated to hold up your end.
 
i agree with a lot of the previous posters. i think you need to really take a long hard look at this and see if you''re willing to cling on and read into mixed signals at any cost just to keep the relationship going.

what i see (from your post) is him flat out saying he has a lot of doubts, no fireworks, not sure, not the one...all kinds of red flags showing that he''s starting to want out. What you did was drop everything and rush to his place and confront him. He then felt bombarded and probably guilty (rightfullly seeing how it was v-day!) which led to a lot of back peddling (guys do this to get out of uncomfortable situations--like a gf standing right there grilling you). Unfortunately I think he was pretty upfront and honest in that original phone call even though it was harsh and insensitive timing. You might want to start preparing for the worst (which really isn''t the worst, b/c who wants to be with someone who''s only half in it?).

i always get a little suspicious of situations where the girl says she''s not that into sentimental stuff (v-day etc), b/c often it''s jsut the guy who''s lazy and not into it and the girls'' just convinced herself it''s ok to make it acceptable to stick around.

you deserve more!
 
I’m so sorry that this has happened to you. I know how much you love your man and how much effort you have put into your relationship. Knowing those things makes it all the harder to say that I have to side with Mediterranean on her very well thought out response. You should read and re-read what she has said because her points are incredibly valid and unlike those of us who have had the pleasure of bantering back and forth with you on this board for awhile, she hasn’t grown fearful of hurting you by being straightforward and honest (whereas that is exactly how I feel).

First off, because I feel so strongly about this, I have to say that while the actions one may go through to show their love for another may become subtle as the years go by, I definitely do not think that love itself is subtle. Not in the least. When it comes to people I love, there are always fireworks in my heart for them. To be honest, it’s the only way I can differentiate between people I love and people who I like and care deeply about but they just don't have the special stuff to ignite the fuse on my fireworks.

You had The Talk with him a few weeks ago. Since then he’s done a lot of thinking and he concluded that he does not see a definitive future with you. From my perspective he followed through with what you wanted to be told: if he saw a future or not. I feel like he took a lot of time to think the situation over and came to his conclusion. I am sure he does care about you and that is exactly why he felt badly the moment he was actually faced with how badly he hurt you.

Deco pointed out some interesting things as well. For instance, he called you at work to tell you this. Perhaps he took a non-confrontational approach because he was fearful he would be unable to get out what he needed to say to you and he would waffle the moment he saw how hurt you were. He may have figured if he called you at work, he would avoid a teary situation. A dirty secret I hold within myself is that I actually broke up with my last SO over breakfast in a diner so that I wouldn’t get sucked into a profound discussion and risk walking back into what I knew was a dead end relationship. It’s not the best thing I have ever done in my life but I knew the moment I saw him hurt, I would become weak and could fall for his arguments against a breakup. I chose this route because we had been down the road you are on now: a break-up was proposed, evidence against a break-up was discussed and in the end I caved and we went back to “starting over”. While there was a brief feeling of renewal in the relationship, it was short lived. Years later, we are very good friends and I do care deeply for him, he just never ignited the fuse on my fireworks.

Like many others here have advised, take some time away from each other. Let him decide if he really wants you in his life or if he just thinks he does. There’s a hell of a difference between the two.

Good luck and please make sure you keep us informed of how YOU are doing.
 
Date: 2/15/2008 3:25:48 PM
Author: janinegirly

i always get a little suspicious of situations where the girl says she''s not that into sentimental stuff (v-day etc), b/c often it''s jsut the guy who''s lazy and not into it and the girls'' just convinced herself it''s ok to make it acceptable to stick around.
That''s not the case with me. I ALWAYS hated Valentine''s Day. Not just due to this particular guy, but in general, ever since I was in grade school and I watched some girls be devistated by not getting Valentines or being "popular." Like those "Every Kiss Begins With Kay" commercials. I just think it''s manipulative for people to have to feel obligated to show love in a specific way and by a specific day. I guess it''s just the Marketing major (my first degree; I also have an Art degree) in me. I can spot "marketing" verses emotion a mile away. I''m a romantic - but for romance''s sake, if that makes any sense.

Bridget in Connecticut.
 
I''m fairly new here too, but I wanted to give you a big hug too. On Valentine''s day...I can''t believe it.

I''m going to echo what other ladies have said already. Valentine''s day. On the phone. Yuck. I''m fairly young (27), but I''ll say it anyway. It sounds like your BF is really, really serious about you. He cares for you a lot. He is also very confused. I have hunch that he is absolutely happy and comfortable when you are together, but when he is alone he starts thinking about your future and gets freaked out. He probably doesn''t want another failed relationship.

It would be a little easier if men say straight out "I need to think about our relationship some more. Please give me some time.", but these are creatures who can''t figure out what they need for themselves. He is so confused that all he could blurt out was "I''m not feeling it". Just like men need to decode our language, we need to decode theirs too. Even though he may be crushed, and I KNOW he will be crushed, I think the best thing to do here is to LEAVE him for a month. Maybe more. He''s not going to know that it''s what he needs right now, but at the end of it I''m certain that he will appreciate you for it. I think he will come back too.

It''s hard, but he needs to know that at least one of you knows what she wants in a relationship, and that if he is not able to give it to you then you will find it elsewhere. And I''m not saying this to tell you to play games. This is the truth. After 1.5 years he is freaking out. You don''t need this, and he needs space (I repeat, he probably doesn''t know he needs space).

I hope you don''t think I''m insensitive...I was in a relationship where the guy was so wonderful and we were so happy. Then he started freaking out over the phone and all he repeated was a vague "I don''t know...". I was so crazy about him that anything other than "I want to break up" was a sign that we still had a chance. In the end, what he did was disappear. He was such a coward that he couldn''t even break up with me. I was so naive that I was clinging on to the corpse of our "relationship". The sticker to me was, even if he was weird on the phone, when we were together it was perfect. I see now that he just didn''t want to do the nasty business of breaking up. He wanted me to say it. And all of this analysis, he probably didn''t even realize on his own.

I hope you will find happiness, and I hope he will come to his senses. When he does, make sure that under no circumstances you will tolerate his immaturity again.
 
I just wanted to say that I''m sorry you''re hurting. I''ve read a lot of your posts, and it really comes across what an intelligent and caring person you are.

I, like several others who have responded, doubt whether he will be able to be sure in the end. But that is based on my past experience, and I truly hope that your situation will be different.

In the end, do what you feel is best for you and your relationship. I truly think that no matter how it turns out, following your instinct is the best way to ensure you will have peace of mind about the outcome. You are smart and know how to take care of yourself, so trust your gut. If you need more time to work on things and you''re not ready to walk away yet, that''s okay. If it ends up that things resolve themselves and he really is the one for you, then great. If not and he''s not able to commit, you will have the peace of mind that you did everything you could on your end. If you trust yourself to make the right decision for you at this point in time, then I don''t see how you''ll be able to have any regrets down the road.
 
Date: 2/15/2008 3:25:48 PM
Author: janinegirly

i always get a little suspicious of situations where the girl says she's not that into sentimental stuff (v-day etc), b/c often it's jsut the guy who's lazy and not into it and the girls' just convinced herself it's ok to make it acceptable to stick around.

you deserve more!
Don't read too much into it. I also don't like V-day for the same reasons Bridget stated. I seriously think it's one of the most ridiculous holidays. My motto is, if you love someone, you love them all year around, not just on one day. I also don't understand why so many people would want to share a restaurant with a million other couples. It's over crowded and just lame IMO. I told my bf at the very beginning of our relationship that I absolutely refuse to celebrate it. Even though over the years a bunch of guys (that I wasn't even dating!) always gave me stuff. But our first year my bf gave me one of those heart shaped boxes of chocolates with a cute note saying "I know you don't like Valentines but I know you love chocolate." It was was adorable and I appreciated it and it was the first and only time we have done anything in 5 years. I'm much more about anniversaries (including the semi-anni which is very important to me, it's already been set as our w-day), birthdays, and Christmas.
 
Date: 2/15/2008 3:40:08 PM
Author: Keepingthefaith21







Like many others here have advised, take some time away from each other. Let him decide if he really wants you in his life or if he just thinks he does. There’s a hell of a difference between the two.

First off, THANK YOU, ladies, for the comments/opinions. It's what's keeping me sane here in work today. My boss knows something is up with me (I don't hide my feelings well - I keep things professional, but it's written all over my face) but I think he is afraid to ask.....

Well, I just had an interesting phone call. From you-know-who. My work phone doesn't allow me to see who is calling; had I known it was him, I would have let it go to voicemail. He asked me how I was doing, and I said, "Fine" and didn't say anything else. He wanted to know what time I was getting out of here (work) and I said, "The usual time." And then he said, "Why are you being so short with me?" So I said something to the effect of (and thank you for the inspiration on this):

"I have been feeling like an idiot all day, because I didn't fully realize that you were trying to tell me that you wanted out of our relationship. So, if that's what you want, then you got it. I apologize for making you feel guilty or trying to reason with you - my bad there."

So....long silence, and then he said, "No, MY bad. You are 100% right. I was having doubts and I need to get my head out of my @ss."

And then I said, "Seriously. I have to get back to work here (not a lie - I am working at getting quotes on a project). You made your statement, I am listening to you now and...."

He interrupted me and apologized for interrupting me and said, "Give me points for being human, OK? What is that phrase - "Even Christ had his moments of doubt."

To which I replied, "My friend Rich has a wise saying about men that I am also listening to now: When a man tells you something, believe every word he says. So, I believe you."

And he said, "You opened my eyes and made me think. Sometimes I look at my world with a little tiny flashlight and need someone to shine a big huge spotlight on things. You did that. I was wrong. And I thought we had a plan in place here."

And I said, "Do you really think that living together for a month is going to help you make up your mind about me/us? I mean, really."

And he said, "Well, it will get rid of the doubts in my mind - either prove them right or make me realize that they were unfounded. Don't you think?"

And I said, "I don't really know what to think right now. But I will tell you this: Regardless of what happens, I WILL NOT be held to your ex-wife's measure. Get yourself some help to deal with your feelings about her. I should never have to deal with that. I don't make you responsible for what my ex-husband did to me - I see a therapist for that stuff. I will NOT get clobbered by your baggage anymore. Enough of the emotional roller coaster bulls**t. Got that? Now, I really have to go. We are not open on Monday and I need to get this project rolling before the weekend."

He was, like, "OK. I guess I will see you after work, then." I just said, "Bye."

So I really don't know what to think. I have to stop over his house after work, like it or not, because my overnight bag is over there and critical things (like my contact lens cleaner and make-up) are in it. I was on the fence as to whether or not I want to see him play or not tonight. I was initially planning not -- until this conversation happened and now I don't know.

He's not a game-player kind of guy or a mess-with-your-head kind of guy. I didn't cry, simper, waffle, etc. at him, so no need for him to feel like back-peddling. I gave him an out here and he didn't take it! And why did he even call me at work AGAIN? Was he genuinely concerned about my feelings or was this another attempt at trying to get out of it (because, I did give him the option in as flat an emotional tone as I can muster right now)?

Pardon the rudeness, but WTF?

Bridget in Connecticut.
 
sandia, first of all, I'm sorry you're dealing with this, it' never fun. I know that. You've been given some extraordinary advice so I'm just going to "WORD!" it all and not repeat. What I would say (and KUDOS to you for saying what you did today!) is now that you're on a "me first!" roll, just go get your bag, be nice to him but firm, and tell him you dont want to see him for a month (instead of a move in trial, do a separation trial). To me, THAT is a far more telling way to "know" if he/you want to be together. If you move in, you get your child further into a scenario that might be just a fleeting fantasy (if it doesn't work out) and will be more devastating to your son that to you, yes? So why not take a "Sandia first!" approach to YOU make the decision to do a trial separation. See how YOU feel at the end of a month or two. You might be surprised to learn that you don't really miss this guy after all. Right now, you're too intertwined to think about it objectively. And in that interim, I'd encourage you to get some god counseling so you have someone guiding you through your feelings. You'll come out the other side a stronger, clearer person, IMO. Best of luck sweetie!
 
First of all, I''m so sorry you''re going through this -- I have been in a similar situation, and even though it worked out for me, it stinks big time.

I''ll have to agree with the other ladies here, and say widen the gap. I read your latest post, and it''s good that he''s coming to his senses, but I wouldn''t let this go so easily. What happened in the last few days is no small matter, and "I''m sorry, I made a mistake" is not enough to fix it. You are now having doubts as to his intentions, and he needs to prove his intentions for you. Definitely do not move in with him, as that won''t change anything. Your absence is the only thing that lead him to his true feelings.

You''ve been there for him for the past year and a half -- accommodating his every need, well perhaps it''s time let him accommodate you for a change. I agree with Mediterranean that a woman being good to her man, and showing what a good wife she''d make will not make him change his mind about marrying her. In fact, it won''t even get his attention. When you stop being good to him, that will get his attention.

I''m not saying you should walk away right now because you don''t seem ready, but do give it some space.

You''re a wonderful lady, and should be treated as such. I hope you settle for nothing less!
 
I'm very proud of you.
What you did in that conversation is say, I will not come running towards you at the slightest glimpse of an apology.
He is the one who said he's not feelin it and he needs to live with those words for a while. He wouldn't have said them at the time if he didn't mean them.
And if you shined a big spotlight on his life then I think that's great.

But, just imagine what realizations he can come to if you just leave him in his own world without you for a few weeks. If he's made this big of a turnaround in 12 hours AND TRUELY FEELS IT AND MEANS IT - then go ahead and aim for the turnaround you deserve. You have perpetually been the giver in this relationship. Always holding his hand and lifting his chin up. Now - he's hurt you - in very poor taste, too. Your nicey nice "that's okay" and still go to his band is not sending a very strong message. It actually gives him the right in the future to be nilly willy on his decisions again and again because you'll always be right back there for him.

I'm not saying you should be mean to him. I'm not saying you shouldn't talk about it. But I wouldn't spend the night at his house. I wouldn't watch his band play unless it was with your girlfriends and you left with them - looking super hot too by the way. And I wouldn't call him or text him - EVER - but I would talk if he called.

You don't want to end up like the girl in Med's post. He has to want you and need you in his life. He won't take you just because you're always already there.
 
On second thought ... a "one month trial" move in ... is kind of INFURIATING.
29.gif
Who does that? How comfortable could that *possibly* be? You''d be on pins & needles trying to be the perfect girlfriend and AUDITIONING for the role of partner.

Moving forward in a relationship takes a leap of FAITH by both parties. Geez. He doesn''t even have to MOVE! But he''s willing to give it a "trial run".
20.gif


And, so, you shined a big spotlight over his issue so he sees clearly now -- um, what''s to stop him from hurting you over & over and over again with his big head up his *** if all he has is a "flashlight" view of things???? Tell him to buy some bulbs & call you after a year of therapy!
29.gif


Aiiigh. I''M enraged & its not even happening to me ... but I guess its because we can all relate. And its an awful feeling.
 
hmm what a tough situation...especially reading it all laid out there. and on valentine's day. seriously men really are brain dead sometimes.

it's so tough to say what is or isn't happening. you are deeply inside the whole thing so yeah, your view is colored. you love this man, you want to spend your life with him. as deco said it's the small details in the relationship that mean the most to you. as they should in a way.

but yeah, he calls you up and says he's not feeling it? doesn't see a future with you? wow, that is a pretty blatant statment. i almost also feel like he felt like he should give it another try based on what you said so that he doesn't seem like an a$$.

seriously? i would not move in with him for a month. you mentioned about how entertwined you are thus far. how much harder is it going to be if you live with him for a month and he is like yeah no sorry it's not you, it's me..blah blah. then you are that much more entertwined and it's THAT much more painful. and painful it will be.

i almost think you should tell him that you guys need a break. take a walk away from it, both of you. he sees this big hole if you aren't in his life one minute but the minute before he doesn't see a future with you. does he want YOU in his life or just 'someone'...?? personally i don't have a lot of patience for someone who can't see how friggin fabulous i am and want to be with me forever after 1.5 years...i basically told my now-husband the same thing then (nicer though!!) and gave him a 6 month period to figure it out...he didn't have to propose but there wasn't going to be any 'i'm not sure' going on. guys will float along forever if given the chance, well not all guys but many.

anyhow, i do think you are seeing some things clearly but muddled a bit on others...it's understandable. you are totally confused right now. but think of yourself and your son as FIRST priorities. this man is confused. it's not your job to fix that for him! resist the urge. if you guys have been together this long and he's hemming and hawing like this and wants a month to live with you (seriously after being with you this long??)...to 'see'...it sounds like it's just a final way for him to say 'see it didn't work out, nothing changed and i'm over it'. that stuff drives me crazy. i firmly believe that if after this long they don't know then a month of living together won't make it any clearer.

please think of yourself first.
 
Also, think about this.
What would you learn about him from living with him for one month? What specifically?

Are those things that would make you say, Gosh you know what? I can't spend the rest of my life with this guy.

Then what is it that he thinks he's gonna learn? "I Don't Know" is not an acceptable answer.
You know why? Cause the idea is bad. At this stage in the relationship you're either in it and leaping, smiling, holidng hands, or you're walkin away.

You both just need time to think about it - and not just the weekend. Really decide what it is that's keeping that leap from happening.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top