Opinion on platinum band

[junebug17]

Thanks for the feedback tyty333, Julienyc, loralea, minousbijoux, texaskj, yssie, and Charmypoo - I appreciate you all taking the time to comment and value your opinions!

 

[justginger]

I guess I am the odd one out here and will give my honest opinion. I don't like it from the pics. The setting looks very modern to me (although I am not clear if there is vintagy engraving on the band). The stone is vintage and your band is very classic. It just looks a bit mish mash to me. Sorry but wanted to give you my honest opinion.

ETA: Regardless of my thoughts on the set together, I think each individual piece is gorgeous. I would keep the Scott Kay band for sure! It is stunning.

I will sort of piggy back on Charmy - I don't love them together. But not because of different styling, just because of the gap. I personally don't like big gaps. I think if you shove a spacer in between them, like a mini-stack, it will look like a more comfortable arrangement to my eyes. Some people dig gaps though, you may be one of them.

I can't believe you picked up such a fab deal though - $400?!

 

[junebug17]

Thanks JG! It's funny, when I first came to PS I didn't care for the look of a gap, but now I kind of like it! Especially with non-matching styles of rings. Funny how preferences change.

 

[justginger]

Thanks JG! It's funny, when I first came to PS I didn't care for the look of a gap, but now I kind of like it! Especially with non-matching styles of rings. Funny how preferences change.

That's very true - even in just a few years here, I've started liking things I never considered before, and went off things that I was sure were timeless! It's an expensive hobby for indecisive people like myself.