Crystallized Carbon
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2023
- Messages
- 48
Hi all,
I've been lurking for about ~1 month and finally created an account. I'm on the hunt for my perfect ring and am struggling to locate it. Before I cave and go the old diamond with a new/reproduction setting route, I'd be incredibly appreciative of any help/guidance you all may have in finding a true antique beauty!
Ideal specifications:
So far, I've tried all of the vendors listed in the pinned post, Etsy, 1st Dibs, eBay, etc. etc. I'm located in Australia, so it's been a struggle to find much in person, though I've also visited ~6 local antique/pawn shops. The closest I've come to The One is the following:

My only hesitation with it is that the videos I've seen don't indicate much sparkle and almost no fire. Disappointing! Do you think the setting is not letting in enough light?
I also love this ring, which has already sold (much to my dismay): https://pebbleandpolish.com/product...ia-1-59-carat-old-european-cut-diamond-center
Apologies for the long-winded post, and thank you so much in advance!
I've been lurking for about ~1 month and finally created an account. I'm on the hunt for my perfect ring and am struggling to locate it. Before I cave and go the old diamond with a new/reproduction setting route, I'd be incredibly appreciative of any help/guidance you all may have in finding a true antique beauty!
Ideal specifications:
- Setting:
- Edwardian or Art Deco — original
- White gold or platinum
- No overtly feminine designs (flowers, butterflies, ribbons tied in a bow)
- Diamond:
- OEC or transitional cut
- .85-1.5 carats
- >=SI2 clarity (eye clean)
- >K color
So far, I've tried all of the vendors listed in the pinned post, Etsy, 1st Dibs, eBay, etc. etc. I'm located in Australia, so it's been a struggle to find much in person, though I've also visited ~6 local antique/pawn shops. The closest I've come to The One is the following:


My only hesitation with it is that the videos I've seen don't indicate much sparkle and almost no fire. Disappointing! Do you think the setting is not letting in enough light?
I also love this ring, which has already sold (much to my dismay): https://pebbleandpolish.com/product...ia-1-59-carat-old-european-cut-diamond-center
Apologies for the long-winded post, and thank you so much in advance!