shape
carat
color
clarity

Scared Boyfriend, Help on an Emerald Diamond

This stone is not an emerald cut diamond. It’s a criss cut or tycoon cut.
Did the jeweler explain to you the difference?

Yes, I think that this is really important. Personally I like that style of cut, but if she wants an emerald cut it's not that.

I say that is someone that would be interested in owning one one day as a fun stone, but I already own an emerald cut diamond that I am happy with.
 
Maybe not helpful, because the stones are very different sized, but I have an emerald cut ring and a bracelet that has tycoon cuts. My ring needs cleaning.

Big difference.

IMG_20200427_084318.jpgIMG_20200427_084538.jpgIMG_20200427_084435.jpg
 
How's your search going? I too have an EC diamond that I purchased before speaking up on this forum. I am not in the trade. Personally I think I was really lucky finding the diamond I purchased.
These are some of the tips and resources I used to narrow down my choices.
United Diamonds had work sheets on parameters covering cut, color, dimension ratios etc.
GIA has fantastic teaching tools to define inclusions and how they can impact a diamond as well as color grading.
An appraiser I previously utilized advised to avoid extremes in cut, " Very and Extremely". Very thick or Extremely thick" . Same goes for the Extremely and Very Thin cut.
Another pointer the appraiser mentioned was forget F/ IF( internally flawless or flawless). Which I basically ignored.
Some purist don't recommend choosing a color grade below the D,E,F range that this cut shows the warmth of a diamond's color. My diamond was graded by GIA as G and it's lovely.( My opinion only and to me that's the one that counts). Today if I were to do it all over again I might go further down color wise and risk a lower grade ( I went with a VVS1) being mindful what the inclusions were and where. The cut and ratios are what gave me the sparkle and hall of mirrors affect I wanted.
I was fortunate that I was able to review the diamonds from Blue Nile in my home before I made my purchase. Many of the diamond companies have great return policies ( this is where Brian Gavin failed miserably with me, which is why I can't recommend them).
As for florescence, it can cause a haze or greasy appearance to a diamond or it can whiten a diamond that has a warmer tone. Again it helps to see the diamond and how it performs in a variety of light circumstances.
As for your intended, it would help to see if your future sister in law can sleuth out some details ( design, color sensitivity, metal preferences, shape). Have future sister in law try on a ring your intended wears or vice versa, you'll have her ring size then. Thank you for including us in this journey, can't wait to see what you choose and the end result.
I'll include a picture of my ring and it's details.
Ratio 1.45
Dimensions 9.09 X 6.26 X 4.07 mm
Crown height 11.2%
Table 63%
Depth 65%
Girdle medium to slightly thick
706157
706038
 
How's your search going? I too have an EC diamond that I purchased before speaking up on this forum. I am not in the trade. Personally I think I was really lucky finding the diamond I purchased.
These are some of the tips and resources I used to narrow down my choices.
United Diamonds had work sheets on parameters covering cut, color, dimension ratios etc.
GIA has fantastic teaching tools to define inclusions and how they can impact a diamond as well as color grading.
An appraiser I previously utilized advised to avoid extremes in cut, " Very and Extremely". Very thick or Extremely thick" . Same goes for the Extremely and Very Thin cut.
Another pointer the appraiser mentioned was forget F/ IF( internally flawless or flawless). Which I basically ignored.
Some purist don't recommend choosing a color grade below the D,E,F range that this cut shows the warmth of a diamond's color. My diamond was graded by GIA as G and it's lovely.( My opinion only and to me that's the one that counts). Today if I were to do it all over again I might go further down color wise and risk a lower grade ( I went with a VVS1) being mindful what the inclusions were and where. The cut and ratios are what gave me the sparkle and hall of mirrors affect I wanted.
I was fortunate that I was able to review the diamonds from Blue Nile in my home before I made my purchase. Many of the diamond companies have great return policies ( this is where Brian Gavin failed miserably with me, which is why I can't recommend them).
As for florescence, it can cause a haze or greasy appearance to a diamond or it can whiten a diamond that has a warmer tone. Again it helps to see the diamond and how it performs in a variety of light circumstances.
As for your intended, it would help to see if your future sister in law can sleuth out some details ( design, color sensitivity, metal preferences, shape). Have future sister in law try on a ring your intended wears or vice versa, you'll have her ring size then. Thank you for including us in this journey, can't wait to see what you choose and the end result.
I'll include a picture of my ring and it's details.
Ratio 1.45
Dimensions 9.09 X 6.26 X 4.07 mm
Crown height 11.2%
Table 63%
Depth 65%
Girdle medium to slightly thick
706157
706038

Whoa last picture isn't the best. David Klass did my setting, my ring is on his Instagram page with a video- that really shows it off.
 
Whoa last picture isn't the best. David Klass did my setting, my ring is on his Instagram page with a video- that really shows it off.

Look at 2 August 2019 that's when the video was posted.
 
How's your search going? I too have an EC diamond that I purchased before speaking up on this forum. I am not in the trade. Personally I think I was really lucky finding the diamond I purchased.
These are some of the tips and resources I used to narrow down my choices.
United Diamonds had work sheets on parameters covering cut, color, dimension ratios etc.
GIA has fantastic teaching tools to define inclusions and how they can impact a diamond as well as color grading.
An appraiser I previously utilized advised to avoid extremes in cut, " Very and Extremely". Very thick or Extremely thick" . Same goes for the Extremely and Very Thin cut.
Another pointer the appraiser mentioned was forget F/ IF( internally flawless or flawless). Which I basically ignored.
Some purist don't recommend choosing a color grade below the D,E,F range that this cut shows the warmth of a diamond's color. My diamond was graded by GIA as G and it's lovely.( My opinion only and to me that's the one that counts). Today if I were to do it all over again I might go further down color wise and risk a lower grade ( I went with a VVS1) being mindful what the inclusions were and where. The cut and ratios are what gave me the sparkle and hall of mirrors affect I wanted.
I was fortunate that I was able to review the diamonds from Blue Nile in my home before I made my purchase. Many of the diamond companies have great return policies ( this is where Brian Gavin failed miserably with me, which is why I can't recommend them).
As for florescence, it can cause a haze or greasy appearance to a diamond or it can whiten a diamond that has a warmer tone. Again it helps to see the diamond and how it performs in a variety of light circumstances.
As for your intended, it would help to see if your future sister in law can sleuth out some details ( design, color sensitivity, metal preferences, shape). Have future sister in law try on a ring your intended wears or vice versa, you'll have her ring size then. Thank you for including us in this journey, can't wait to see what you choose and the end result.
I'll include a picture of my ring and it's details.
Ratio 1.45
Dimensions 9.09 X 6.26 X 4.07 mm
Crown height 11.2%
Table 63%
Depth 65%
Girdle medium to slightly thick
IMG_20190807_132629639_HDR.jpg
1565147134551245281987474243798.jpg

Sorry for the snail mail here! Been preoccupied with this, but thank you for the post. Sounds like if I want to go for a diamond like yours I should focus on colour before clarity.

At this point in time I would honestly just love someone to show me an EC diamond around the 1.5ct mark which is the best in their point of view for around $8.5kUSD and be done with it. But I have got the sister in law to sleuth for me, hopefully I will get more clarity (haha).

In regards to what I believe she likes this is the ring from her Pinterest/what she has shown her sister before.

CEF81D00-BF23-45BC-B744-22DE3B2F0A0A.jpegBFF0558F-3F27-4536-A6AB-40B6D45C8D77.jpeg9247D8D1-1EFD-4CD2-8EDA-8570C91F8D6C.jpeg
 
Maybe not helpful, because the stones are very different sized, but I have an emerald cut ring and a bracelet that has tycoon cuts. My ring needs cleaning.

Big difference.

IMG_20200427_084318.jpgIMG_20200427_084538.jpgIMG_20200427_084435.jpg

Legend! This really helps. I have posted a photo of what she likes, and I think it’s emerald not tycoon?
 
Legend! This really helps. I have posted a photo of what she likes, and I think it’s emerald not tycoon?

Yep. Those are emerald cuts in your Pinterest grabs. The tycoon has extra facets on the table or top of the diamond that are diamond shaped. It's "busier" looking.
 
Legend! This really helps. I have posted a photo of what she likes, and I think it’s emerald not tycoon?

Correct. The photos from her Pinterest are of Emerald Cut diamonds.
:cool2:
 
@age_597 Just for visualization the diamonds in her Pinterest are most likely quite a bit bigger (depending on hand size) than a 1.5 carat. I read that you want a mined and not a lab grown. A lab grown definitely would make you let you stretch the size. But any choice will be beautiful even if it isn’t as big as in her Pinterest!
 
I must have looked at 20 different emerald cut diamonds before I found mine. I think with an EC you really have to see it in person. I don't think you can just go by the numbers. Also an EC cut is basically all mirrors so clarity is extremely important. You just can't skimp on clarity. If there is an inclusion anywhere in the middle it will be reflected all over. My two cents for what it is worth, lol.
 
Sorry for the snail mail here! Been preoccupied with this, but thank you for the post. Sounds like if I want to go for a diamond like yours I should focus on colour before clarity.

At this point in time I would honestly just love someone to show me an EC diamond around the 1.5ct mark which is the best in their point of view for around $8.5kUSD and be done with it. But I have got the sister in law to sleuth for me, hopefully I will get more clarity (haha).

In regards to what I believe she likes this is the ring from her Pinterest/what she has shown her sister before.

CEF81D00-BF23-45BC-B744-22DE3B2F0A0A.jpegBFF0558F-3F27-4536-A6AB-40B6D45C8D77.jpeg9247D8D1-1EFD-4CD2-8EDA-8570C91F8D6C.jpeg

Emerald Cuts are gorgeous! I'd agree with going for color instead of clarity too.
Most times, they can't be seen from the naked eye. However, if you're going for a step-cut diamond like Emerald you have to be careful even with certain VS clarity ranged diamonds. Some can have very visible black inclusions too & the step cut facet can't really hide the inclusions as well as brilliant cuts. Emerald cuts are generally clearer so you see the inclusions a lot easier as it has less reflections.

https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-diamonds/emerald-cut/1.50-carat-h-color-vs1-clarity-sku-8508789 - just to give you a reference, I came across this stone before & you can see that even though it's a VS1 clarity there's multiple visible inclusions. So be careful!
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top