- Joined
- Nov 1, 2007
- Messages
- 4,845
Ahh, Lisa, I don't think there is any stone or piece of jewelry of yours that I don't adore. You are so good at choosing color.
This is best spessartine garnet in my opinion.
Mexican fire opals are not as durable for everyday wear. While they don’t sparkle as much as spessartite garnets, their color can be just as gorgeous. The Fanta spessartites are more expensive than fire opals. Other spessartites are not that expensive. Mine wasn’t. My mom has a 7 carat fire opal ring that is gorgeous. I think fire opals are beautiful. I’m not sure why they aren’t more popular on here. I have that same question about one of my favorite stones, imperial topaz.Hi, I went through all the photos and love the bright Fanta Orange of this stone!
I have a Mexican Fire Opal, and I would like your opinion of a Fire Opal vs. a Spessartite. Ignoring the color which I know will vary between these two gemstones, I am interested in your thoughts on:
- Which stone sparkles more
- Pricepoint (I am looking for a Fanta Orange stone around 12x10mm, how many carats would the be approximately)
- Why are Fire Opals not popular (e.g. why do you prefer a spessartite vs. a Fire Opal), are Spessartites more sparkly? Less included?
I like my Fire Opal. It is a fun ring, and I picked a red-orange stone. However, I could swear when I first purchased it, it was more red and more sparkly. Now it seems a bit cloudy and dull. If any of you experts have any insight on this point, I would appreciate it.
Many thanks!
Mexican fire opals are not as durable for everyday wear. While they don’t sparkle as much as spessartite garnets, their color can be just as gorgeous. The Fanta spessartites are more expensive than fire opals. Other spessartites are not that expensive. Mine wasn’t. My mom has a 7 carat fire opal ring that is gorgeous. I think fire opals are beautiful. I’m not sure why they aren’t more popular on here. I have that same question about one of my favorite stones, imperial topaz.
A pure orange mandarin spessartite in the size you want is going to be very expensive and hard to find. Anything above 2 carats seems rather pricey. Also, spessartite garnets are very heavy stones. They have a high specific gravity. A 10x12 stone will have a high carat weight. I’m sure someone on here can help you find your stone.
Very pretty and feminine! I love that setting.
You’re welcome. I have no doubt you will find what you are looking for. AJS.com has a couple around the size you want. I’ve noticed that a lot of people on here have had to send several garnets back until they found the right one. It’s definitely one of the colored gems that’s better to buy in person, if you can.Thank you for your input. I will definitely look at spessartites. I love the sparkle as you mentioned, and that Fanta Orange! And you said they were more durable is a plus for me since I am hard with my jewelry. Thanks again!
Love the color! A red spess like yours is in my wish list!
Love the color! A red spess like yours is in my wish list!