Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

Tennis Bracelet

P

Pongal713

Rough_Rock
Joined
Dec 1, 2023
Messages
18
I am torn between getting a 6ctw BGD tennis bracelet (F/G, VS, 7in/41/.14, $12.6K) vs costco 12 (G color, VS platinum, 7.5in/ 40 stone/.3 each, 17k) . Both are in a platinum setting. Does anyone own costco 12ct TB?
 
The BGD stones are .14 ct each and Costco’s are .3 ct each???
Which length is better for you? You don’t want to pay for 1/2” of diamonds of excess length you don’t need.
 
headlight said:
The BGD stones are .14 ct each and Costco’s are .3 ct each???
Which length is better for you? You don’t want to pay for 1/2” of diamonds of excess length you don’t need.
Click to expand...

I saw that too but if you do the math, I am guessing the Costco bracelet has .30 diamonds to get to 12 carats.
 
I saw the other Costco 12ctw bracelet in person and it was stunning. I posted a picture on the Costco thread.

Show me your Costco diamonds.

Okay….I’m really torn. This bracelet is shooting rainbows and sparkles all over in the kitchen on a rainy day. I can’t capture how much it sparkles but I tried my best..This is a PRETTY bracelet. I just this second decided I’m keeping it. I’ll put the other one away and sell it at some point so...
www.pricescope.com
 
chere said:
I saw the other Costco 12ctw bracelet in person and it was stunning. I posted a picture on the Costco thread.

Show me your Costco diamonds.

Okay….I’m really torn. This bracelet is shooting rainbows and sparkles all over in the kitchen on a rainy day. I can’t capture how much it sparkles but I tried my best..This is a PRETTY bracelet. I just this second decided I’m keeping it. I’ll put the other one away and sell it at some point so...
www.pricescope.com
Click to expand...

Thanks for posting that. I was looking everywhere for actual picture. My costco doesn't have any TB on display. This is the current listing they have.Screenshot_20240129_192304_Gallery.jpg
 
I have the 6 ctw BGD bracelet you are looking at and it’s an incredible stunner. BGD uses their highest quality signature cut diamonds in their tennis bracelets. The two bracelets you are considering are different not only in size, but also in settings. The BGD bracelet is a three-prong setting, which has a different look than the Costco four-prong setting. Are you drawn to either setting more? FYI, if you decide to also consider Whiteflash, which is very similar to BGD, they no longer use their highest quality cut diamonds in their tennis bracelets. When I inquired about upgrading to those, it raised the price more than 30%.
 
shelleydog said:
I have the 6 ctw BGD bracelet you are looking at and it’s an incredible stunner. BGD uses their highest quality signature cut diamonds in their tennis bracelets. The two bracelets you are considering are different not only in size, but also in settings. The BGD bracelet is a three-prong setting, which has a different look than the Costco four-prong setting. Are you drawn to either setting more? FYI, if you decide to also consider Whiteflash, which is very similar to BGD, they no longer use their highest quality cut diamonds in their tennis bracelets. When I inquired about upgrading to those, it raised the price more than 30%.
Click to expand...

I know 2 different settings but the 3 prong setting from BGD will make it look bigger( 41 x3.4mm in 3 prong vs. 3.2mm in 4 prong). I got quoted $13650 with platinum setting(plus 1k off for current promo so 12650). I asked for an actual picture on hand of the 6ct 3 prong but they only have 5ct available. Bgd with melee cannot be upgraded only signature BGD diamonds. I have BGD pendant in martini setting and it looks spectacular (i had to make sure it wasn't bezel so i can upgrade in the future). I am torn since you don't get to see what it looks like and custom pieces are final sale. Then you have costco TB which is a 4 prong but 30 pointer. Not ideal cut like BGD, so I don't know how much it would sparkle. Also I haven't seen it but returnable. My wrist is 5in and would need it to be 5.5-5.75 bracelet length.
 
Henrik said:
I don't have the Costco 12ct TB, but I've got a 6ctw BGD tennis bracelet, and it's been a solid choice.
Click to expand...

Did you get 3 or 4 prong?
 
I understand your concern about custom pieces. I felt the same way so I purchased mine without having it shortened which allowed me to have an inspection period. Here’s my BGD 3-prong 6 ctw (before it was shortened). I bought it last month and wear it every day. The diamonds are 14.7 pointers. I returned it to BGD to be shortened to 6.25 inches after I wore it a few days to determine the length I wanted. I incurred additional expense for return shipping and shortening it, but it allowed me to have an inspection period and decide the length. I am in awe of it every day.IMG_5390.jpegIMG_5393.jpeg
 
shelleydog said:
I understand your concern about custom pieces. I felt the same way so I purchased mine without having it shortened which allowed me to have an inspection period. Here’s my BGD 3-prong 6 ctw (before it was shortened). I bought it last month and wear it every day. The diamonds are 14.7 pointers. I returned it to BGD to be shortened to 6.25 inches after I wore it a few days to determine the length I wanted. I incurred additional expense for return shipping and shortening it, but it allowed me to have an inspection period and decide the length. I am in awe of it every day.IMG_5390.jpegIMG_5393.jpeg
Click to expand...

I am leaning towards BGD now. What made you choose 3 prong over 4?
 
Henrik said:
I don't have the Costco 12ct TB, but I've got a 6ctw BGD tennis bracelet, and it's been a solid choice.
Click to expand...

Please post pics...I would love to see it.
 
Pongal713 said:
I am leaning towards BGD now. What made you choose 3 prong over 4?
Click to expand...

Both are beautiful, but I feel like less metal shows on the three prong than the four prong. For the same tcw, the three prong has larger stones because there’s less of them. And the individual stones show more than on the four prong, which appears more as a line.

I had a great experience working with BGD. I have purchased from them several times. In fact, they are currently making custom jackets for my studs.
 
shelleydog said:
Both are beautiful, but I feel like less metal shows on the three prong than the four prong. For the same tcw, the three prong has larger stones because there’s less of them. And the individual stones show more than on the four prong, which appears more as a line.

I had a great experience working with BGD. I have purchased from them several times. In fact, they are currently making custom jackets for my studs.
Click to expand...

This is the first time I will be buying a TB. Does ideal cut make a huge difference even if the diamonds are 14 pointers?
 
I definitely saw a difference in the bracelets I looked at locally from my BGD bracelet, but I don’t know what their stats were.
 
Pongal713 said:
This is the first time I will be buying a TB. Does ideal cut make a huge difference even if the diamonds are 14 pointers?
Click to expand...

I think yes, it makes a difference, and you could see the difference if you looked at them side-by-side. But since you won’t be constantly comparing your bracelet to another one, I think it depends on how much extra you have to pay and if you’re happy without going super ideal. Like, will you always be wondering and wishing you had just spent a little more to get “perfection”? I found that IDJ’s pricescope quality diamonds were a happy medium between Costco and a super ideal in terms of price and performance.
 
I highly recommend trying on bracelets at a jeweler or ordering CZ bracelets off Amazon to try. Then you can gage if you want 15 or 30 point stones. Also a 4 prong and 3 prong setting are completely different looks. It's best to see them in person.

To @mayaINaU's point, I went for best value and got a 4ctw Costco tennis bracelet for $2,500 after the sales. It was appraised as EFG, VVS-VS, Excellent cut. It sparkles like crazy. I don't think I would pay a premium for super ideal melee stones in a tennis bracelet. I would rather spend the money on size. It depends on what you value more.
 
This image isn’t perfect but hopefully it will give you some sense of scale:

IMG_7814.jpeg
 
chere said:
I highly recommend trying on bracelets at a jeweler or ordering CZ bracelets off Amazon to try. Then you can gage if you want 15 or 30 point stones. Also a 4 prong and 3 prong setting are completely different looks. It's best to see them in person.

To @mayaINaU's point, I went for best value and got a 4ctw Costco tennis bracelet for $2,500 after the sales. It was appraised as EFG, VVS-VS, Excellent cut. It sparkles like crazy. I don't think I would pay a premium for super ideal melee stones in a tennis bracelet. I would rather spend the money on size. It depends on what you value more.
Click to expand...

So what is more important in a TB? Size or cut?
 
Testers are a great idea.

Or, if you really want to be certain, you can buy both to compare side by side irl and then return one.
 
Pongal713 said:
So what is more important in a TB? Size or cut?
Click to expand...

Depends on the person. For me, both. I ordered different sizes on amazon (brand Pavoi) to see what weight I was comfortable with. From there I decided I really wanted ideal so considered Brian Gavin, Whiteflash (ACA) and Wink. I wanted 6-10 carat and was thrilled with the personal service I received from Wink, and was fortunate enough that I was able to get .30ct h+a diamonds within our budget. Good luck on your decision.
 
jokerja said:
I have the 3 pong tennis bracelet and it's something. Looks insane.
Click to expand...

I see that you are trade but do you have a picture of your tennis bracelet? Would love to see it!
 
prettypaper01 said:
Depends on the person. For me, both. I ordered different sizes on amazon (brand Pavoi) to see what weight I was comfortable with. From there I decided I really wanted ideal so considered Brian Gavin, Whiteflash (ACA) and Wink. I wanted 6-10 carat and was thrilled with the personal service I received from Wink, and was fortunate enough that I was able to get .30ct h+a diamonds within our budget. Good luck on your decision.
Click to expand...

Thank you for your kind words. It was a fun project.
 
Update: I received my Costco tennis bracelet today. The diamonds are white and with lots of sparkle. 20240206_184009.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 20240206_185515.jpg
    20240206_185515.jpg
    70.2 KB · Views: 46
  • 20240206_185304.jpg
    20240206_185304.jpg
    122.9 KB · Views: 46
  • 20240206_185245.jpg
    20240206_185245.jpg
    92 KB · Views: 46
  • 20240206_185050.jpg
    20240206_185050.jpg
    106.1 KB · Views: 44
That's STUNNING! I have a 5ctw bracelet from Costco and I LOVE it!

How do you feel about this one?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top