Which Emerald Cut Has the least Windowing?

[robro]

Hi everyone, I'm about to purchase an emerald cut engagement ring but am very wary of buying a diamond with bad windowing.

It would mean the world if someone could help me evaluate the 3 diamonds I've been offered. I'm leaning towards the 3rd option since the 360 video looks like there's less 'black' shadows but I could be completely off the mark here.

Any advice would be much appreciated

Option 1: IGI cert 2.04 Emerald diamond - E vs1 exe exe

• 360 video

Options 2: IGI cert 2.02 E Vs1 exe exe

• 360 video

Option 3: IGI cert 2.02 E vvs2 exe exe

• 360 video

IGI Reports attached below as well!

 

[robro]

@Karl_K are you able to help me please? I've heard you're the expert!

 

[Karl_K]

3rd is the one worth considering.
Can you get more images? IS\ASET?
I cant check the crystal on here hopefully one of the prosumers will weigh in.

 

[robro]

3rd is the one worth considering.
Can you get more images? IS\ASET?
I cant check the crystal on here hopefully one of the prosumers will weigh in.

Thanks so much for this. You're a lifesaver.

Unfortunately there's no ASET images but thanks for your help. I'll wait to see if there's anyone else who can weigh in about the crystals but otherwise will have to pull the trigger on 3.

 

[newtojewels]

I am not an expert, mostly trying to learn myself. Is this a crystal issue on #3?

 

[Karl_K]

I am not an expert, mostly trying to learn myself. Is this a crystal issue on #3?

Yes, it has some crystal issues.