Which setting?

[MustangFan]

http://www.antiqueengagementringsonline.com/jewelry.cfm/Antique-Engagement-Rings/ANTIQUE-STYLE-SET-R0177-more-images2.html

http://www.alaskajewelry.com/popup_image.php?pID=604

 

[jokerselsa]

I think they are both Beautiful, But I think I like the detail of the first one.
I dont believe I have ever seen rounds on the side like that,but it looks really pretty,and I''m sure would highlight the center stone nicely.

The second one is very unique also. But IMO, The first one.

 

[MustangGal]

The second one looks like the band might wear bad against the e-ring and cause issues later on. I also hate peg heads, so I''m a little biased towards the first one.

 

[Gypsy]

DEFINITELY the second from alaskajewerlry that one is a winner. No contest... I dont'' like the clustered trio of diamonds on the first one when you compare it with the bezeled pear and round on the shank of the second. Second. Hands down.

 

[glitterata]

I''m with Gypsy on this. (Also, Gypsy, congrats on your new job!)

 

[Gypsy]

Thank you Glitterata! I''m excited. And I still have two days to enjoy before I start!

 

[E B]

I love the second, from Simon G.

 

[FireGoddess]

Simon G (the second setting) NO DOUBT ABOUT IT, HANDS DOWN!!!! I have seen that set in person and it is so drop dead gorgeous. I wanted to walk out with it even though I already had my halo setting. I took my SIL to a jeweler to design a custom wedding band and she ended up getting one made that was modified off the wedding band of this Simon G set. It''s AWESOME!!!!!

 

[flutterby]

I have to agree on the second one as well. What a gorgeous setting!

 

[ilovesparkles]

Hands down the second setting but I hate the head. Could you put a mire elegant head in there?

 

[froufrou]

the second one is so pretty~

 

[MustangFan]

Sparkles, what is a mire elegant head???
I would need to change the head on that one anyway because I want to use a pear if he gets it.

I almost know for a fact that he is going to get the Simon G. He picked it out actually and that''s his favorite so far. I also found a halo setting with bead set diamonds on the sides made by Stardust but I can''t find it online!!!!

FireGodess your pear halo bezel set is one of my favorite ring shots on here, does that company make a heart shape just like that????? Please let me know because he loves the idea of a heart sapphire with diamonds around it.

 

[lizz]

I like the first one. The second one is pretty, but I think those bezel-set rounds sticking out would get on my nerves after awhile.

 

[MustangFan]

I know what you mean lizz... the round bezel right on the end I''m not crazy over either arrgghhh, if I tell him that he''s going to spend himself to a mental institution. lol