Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

2 new choices ..... pics attached

U

Undecided79

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jul 28, 2017
Messages
61
IMG_2396.JPG So I am so indecisive and I have narrowed it to 2 diff rings and need some input ! I so appreciate it . I am remounting my 1 carat princess cut into a new setting. What are your thoughts on these two? IMG_2383.JPG
 
Undecided79 said:
IMG_2396.JPG So I am so indecisive and I have narrowed it to 2 diff rings and need some input ! I so appreciate it . I am remounting my 1 carat princess cut into a new setting. What are your thoughts on these two? IMG_2383.JPG
Click to expand...
Does first one look dated or no?
 
It's a little hard to see from the picture but is the second one a split shank? I like that one better. I think your stone stands out more. Love your nail color too!
 
Last edited:
Bonfire said:
It's a little hard to see from the picture but is the second one a split shank? I like that one better. I think your stone stands out more.
Click to expand...
IMG_2389.JPG
 
Oh I see better now, thank you. It isn't a split shank but I still like that one better. To me the first one sort of dwarfs your stone somewhat. What do you think? Which one do you like better?
 
Both are pretty - I prefer the second, I think your stone gets a little lost in the first one.
 
Bonfire said:
Oh I see better now, thank you. It isn't a split shank but I still like that one better. To me the first one sort of dwarfs your stone somewhat. What do you think? Which one do you like better?
Click to expand...
I'm honestly so undecided. Do you think the first looks dated ? I can't make a decision and my hubby is beyond done w me asking his opinion lol
 
junebug17 said:
Both are pretty - I prefer the second, I think your stone gets a little lost in the first one.
Click to expand...
Thankyou . I am driving my husband nuts. I think lol. Do you think the first is dated looking at all or no?
 
Also one is at the jewelry exchange, has anyone heard any good or bad about them? Making sure it is reputable. I see the commercials on tv all the time
 
Both settings are very similar. Maybe that's why you are having trouble deciding? Whichever setting you choose, please come back with pictures.
 
We purchased my rings at the Jewelry Exchange. We had a great experience with them. The associates were friendly and very helpful. We made three or four visits before deciding on a stone and they never pressured us to buy.
 
I know exactly how you feel, trying to decide is torturous sometimes! No, I don't think the first one is dated at all.
 
junebug17 said:
I know exactly how you feel, trying to decide is torturous sometimes! No, I don't think the first one is dated at all.
Click to expand...
Agreed! I'm glad I am not the only one
 
mom2dolls said:
We purchased my rings at the Jewelry Exchange. We had a great experience with them. The associates were friendly and very helpful. We made three or four visits before deciding on a stone and they never pressured us to buy.
Click to expand...
This makes me feel good because I wasn't sure about them. If you read reviews they aren't always good.
 
Thanks for your input! I will let you know my choice ! If I ever make one
 
I also like the second one better - it seems to showcase the center stone whilst the first one overwhelms it a bit.
 
Ooh, must be so tough to decide. I actually like the first design. You have very long and slender fingers: the first ring fills it up nicely. And I love the bead set/channel set look.
 
So...have you decided undecided??? :D
 
IMG_2424.PNG IMG_2423.PNG
junebug17 said:
So...have you decided undecided??? :D
Click to expand...
Hi there. So I have ruled out one. The thicker one. I am still stuck between these 2. My husband said he can't see a difference. Lol. Maybe you can ..... cause we get it.
 
Undecided79 said:
IMG_2424.PNG IMG_2423.PNG
Hi there. So I have ruled out one. The thicker one. I am still stuck between these 2. My husband said he can't see a difference. Lol. Maybe you can ..... cause we get it.
Click to expand...
And I love your joke!
 
The diff is one is more flat And one more cathedral setting but very similar.
 
I think I prefer the first - the only thing is it looks like there's a bezel on the side of the ring, and a band might not sit flush alongside it? I don't mind a gap but I don't know how you feel.

And my husband would say the same thing as yours lol!
 
Bonfire said:
It's a little hard to see from the picture but is the second one a split shank? I like that one better. I think your stone stands out more. Love your nail color too!
Click to expand...
Is the second one too much bling ? Lol
 
junebug17 said:
I think I prefer the first - the only thing is it looks like there's a bezel on the side of the ring, and a band might not sit flush alongside it? I don't mind a gap but I don't know how you feel.

And my husband would say the same thing as yours lol!
Click to expand...
I know. Is either one too much diamond ? I am going from a plain solitaire so this is big change for me
 
Undecided79 said:
Is the second one too much bling ? Lol
Click to expand...
Only you can answer that. I approach these type of decisions (bling) emotionally. By that I mean, what is my initial reaction. If it's kind of meh, then I should keep looking. If you haven't found the one that shivers your timbers, perhaps you need to keep looking. ;))
 
Out of these two, my choice would be the second
 
I don't think it's too much diamond, I love blingy settings! But of course it doesn't matter what I think, it's what you love that counts!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top