shape
carat
color
clarity

Can someone please help me price this?

pearaffair

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jun 15, 2015
Messages
3,445
I received this ring in a trade with @MakingTheGrade. She’s lovely, the ring is lovely, but it’s not something I’ve worn and I have my eye on something else haha

Can someone help me price it? Because I traded Hazel for it, and received this ring and some money, I’m not sure what a fair price would be. I’m happy to give a PSer a good deal.

The ring seems to be a replica of a Penny Preville design. While I don’t normally go for replicas, it’s a pretty design and 14k white gold with diamonds. The real one goes for $8000 in 18k. (https://www.shetlerfinejewelers.com/catalog/penny-preville/r6022w/)

This ring is not worth nearly that amount haha so please help me out!

Thanks in advance for your advice.AE8D6D92-2991-4636-AAC9-3921BA3549B9.jpeg

(@MakingTheGrade I hope you don’t mind I used some of your photos- they were what was on my phone already and I’m sick in bed so this was easiest.)
 

Attachments

  • 72A181C8-1582-41F6-8C17-25163B30ADAE.jpeg
    72A181C8-1582-41F6-8C17-25163B30ADAE.jpeg
    141.7 KB · Views: 3
  • AEC6237C-3A3F-455D-93A6-E6BCF61BDEF0.jpeg
    AEC6237C-3A3F-455D-93A6-E6BCF61BDEF0.jpeg
    57.6 KB · Views: 3
  • 87B71B1A-8FB1-42DD-BC60-F7828C7E72B7.jpeg
    87B71B1A-8FB1-42DD-BC60-F7828C7E72B7.jpeg
    65.1 KB · Views: 4
  • 284C753D-2EBA-4D18-899C-46BE2FFD23B5.jpeg
    284C753D-2EBA-4D18-899C-46BE2FFD23B5.jpeg
    113.6 KB · Views: 4
  • 39DE4EAE-7B59-4A17-BFD2-6CC36996C3C0.jpeg
    39DE4EAE-7B59-4A17-BFD2-6CC36996C3C0.jpeg
    141.7 KB · Views: 3
D9AC0A41-9127-4C04-8182-55F7E376BD60.jpeg
 
No idea but here to say it's very very pretty. It also looks so good on your finger. Lucky lady.
 
No idea but here to say it's very very pretty. Lucky lady.
Thanks! :)

I’m trying to really narrow and hone my collection. This ring needs a new home! :)
 
Maybe get an appraisal and then slash the amount in half?

Oh that’s a good idea! Appraisals cost me $85 though… not wanting to add that extra to the price if I don’t have to
 
Even in a trade transaction, the ring must have been accorded some dollar value, yes? And, maybe get back to @MakingTheGrade to re-confirm the diamond specs/total carat weight? I know, sometimes our minds go blank when it comes to letting go of pieces, but if you go back to the value you assigned it at the time you acquired it, market check current value re: diamonds and metal value, consider your preferred timeline to sell it, factor in your savvy as a seasoned PSer who has bought and sold on the preloved market ... voila, a price will come to you, I have faith!
 
Even in a trade transaction, the ring must have been accorded some dollar value, yes? And, maybe get back to @MakingTheGrade to re-confirm the diamond specs/total carat weight? I know, sometimes our minds go blank when it comes to letting go of pieces, but if you go back to the value you assigned it at the time you acquired it, market check current value re: diamonds and metal value, consider your preferred timeline to sell it, factor in your savvy as a seasoned PSer who has bought and sold on the preloved market ... voila, a price will come to you, I have faith!

Good idea. I don’t think I asked her for any details on it because I just wanted it (lol) but I will see what I can dig up!
 
What’s the size? I’m very interested in it. Are you open to trade or downsize?
 
I’m sorry to say I’m terrible at keeping documentation for these things unless it’s a gia or ags or official report. I don’t tend to keep receipts or spreadsheets as a private consumer. Sadly I got that ring such a long time ago I don’t remember any details . I can try to see if I maybe made a PS thread though! That’s usually what I do when I resell something and need details haha. I rely on hoping my old self was excited to share and posted details and specs.
 
Ah ha! Success. Hope this helps
 
Thank you @MakingTheGrade ! All those pics are super super helpful! I only wore this ring “out into the wild” for part of one day, so it still looks just like your photos. Hopefully it can stay in the PS family!
 
What’s the size? I’m very interested in it. Are you open to trade or downsize?

I believe it’s a size 6 but I’ll double-check
It’s wide but comfortable

I’m probably not looking to trade unless you have a gold chain necklace, Gucci/mariner link haha… that’s what I have my eye on.

My calculations make me think $1450 USD would be fair, but I’m open to offers! I’ll cover shipping to USA or Canada. Please note that I’m in Canada so duty may be owed if you’re in the USA.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top