- Joined
- Aug 4, 2008
- Messages
- 15,478
There was a period of time where it was a fad to snarl at men who held doors but it seems to have passed.
Kindness (without dark ulterior motives) is always good.
But chivalry has a dark past based on women being considered ... less than.
So, how's 'bout we just retire the term chivalry?
There are other words without baggage so problematic these days.
I asked my DH, "Is chivalry dead?" He said, "What's chivalry?"I guess that means it's dead! Once I explained it...he said it depends
on the situation.
We both agree that holding doors and thanking people for holding doors are just good manners. I would not be interested in him
opening my car door, pushing my chair in, or ordering my food. Those are just on a different level and sort of imply that I cant do
things for myself. I would not be offended if someone did this on a first date to a nice place, however, I would not want a guy
to continue with these practices. Just too formal/old fashioned for me. If I felt any sexism or superior attitude that would obviously
be the last date.
I've been married 25 years so luckily done with dating!
so we may not all be talking about the same things lol
And in the spirit of that, here's something - my husband has always ordered for me, from our first date. However, to him that's not about chivalry, it's about etiquette, and it's something he learned from his mother. So, whenever we're out, just the two of us - he'll ask me what I want and then will order for both of us. If we're out with friends, he'll let me choose whether to order for myself or to tell him what I want and then he'll order for me. I've never found it condescending or perceived it as negative in any way.
And in the spirit of that, here's something - my husband has always ordered for me, from our first date. However, to him that's not about chivalry, it's about etiquette, and it's something he learned from his mother. So, whenever we're out, just the two of us - he'll ask me what I want and then will order for both of us. If we're out with friends, he'll let me choose whether to order for myself or to tell him what I want and then he'll order for me. I've never found it condescending or perceived it as negative in any way.
about what's behind erasing my last name to take on my husband's, I
I dont think its a threadjack (or at least I hope not) but i wanted to just address this part... It always blew my mind when women in America were upset by this. "I'm losing my identity!" or "I refuse to take my husbands last name, it's so misogynistic!" Your maiden name is just SOME OTHER GUYS NAME (your dad). Its literally based on the 'misogynistic' thing that the kid gets the dads last name.
So I am MUCH happier to take my husbands last name. I CHOSE my husband, it was MY decision, i picked him from every man on the earth, it wasnt just decided for me by someone else ... and I mean, at the end of the day, it's just some MANs last name.
So thats my 2 cents on the name thing, maiden name or married name is just some guy's name. I said in America because I know some other countries the last name can come from the maternal side.
As for the chivalry in general, i do think chivalry is how men act towards women. I like it and miss it. I like more traditional gender roles, and I chose a relationship that highlights that. Again, I CHOSE that. I dont care that men think something about me when they see me.
As a general statement, I pretty much dont get offended by anything. I find nowadays *most* people get offended by .... pretty much everything. Being offended is a feeling, so I choose not to allow others to affect me. I decide to rise above it. I can control my emotions.
Being offended is a choice. I choose not to let other people control me.
I have just been through A LOT and I am a very strong woman, so i do not get offended by things. CONTROVERSAL PERSONAL OPINION: Being offended is weakness because you are choosing to allow another person to control how you feel.
I am confident in myself, my beliefs and my values. A man can't "offend me" because he offered to help me with something heavy because he assumes I am weak. Let him think what he wants, i KNOW i am not weak. I am usually confident I can probably lift more than he can. When i am at work and a man assumes I am an assistant and asks me to get him something, I get it for him, what do I care. I KNOW I am a licensed professional and I am completely confident in my abilities. I know I am smarter than he is. So I laugh at him because he's a clown.
I just dont "get" being offended, don't let someone else have power and control over you. Whats someone else thinks or says doesnt change my reality.
I am sure someone will be offended by what I am saying here. Don't be! Dont give me that power over you, I am just some @sshole stranger with a computer. Don't let MY SILLY OPINION occupy any headspace. Just roll your eyes at me and move on. That's what I do when I see something that should "offend" me.
Again, I am focusing on "being offended" NOT on fearing for your safety, those are two vastly different things.
And in the spirit of that, here's something - my husband has always ordered for me, from our first date.
I dont think its a threadjack (or at least I hope not) but i wanted to just address this part... It always blew my mind when women in America were upset by this. "I'm losing my identity!" or "I refuse to take my husbands last name, it's so misogynistic!" Your maiden name is just SOME OTHER GUYS NAME (your dad). Its literally based on the 'misogynistic' thing that the kid gets the dads last name.
So I am MUCH happier to take my husbands last name. I CHOSE my husband, it was MY decision, i picked him from every man on the earth, it wasnt just decided for me by someone else ... and I mean, at the end of the day, it's just some MANs last name.
As a general statement, I pretty much dont get offended by anything. I find nowadays *most* people get offended by .... pretty much everything. Being offended is a feeling, so I choose not to allow others to affect me. I decide to rise above it. I can control my emotions.
Being offended is a choice. I choose not to let other people control me.
I'm going with good manners! I don't care who is exercising them - they are always appreciated.
Yes totally! I’m also chivalrous towards others (including men) when I’m in a position to help and I find that it always results in big smiles and thank yous from everyone involved.
Ooooohh this is a good question!
I’m much like @Inked. I’m fairly traditional and I have always enjoyed chivalry. In fact, I love it. It was something that I always looked for when dating, before I got married.
Can I open doors myself, pay for my half of dinner, carry heavy objects and open pickle jars? Of course I can! But do I love having someone else kindly offer to do that? Why yes I do
Though also if I see anyone who looks as though they might need some help, or if I can open a door for them I do! Men or women, just to be kind and helpful.
Lol the opposite happens here - I as the Mum tend to order for my husband and sons aged 17 & 15. I never presume but pretty much as we read the menu they all end up saying are you ordering for the table? In our case it is about efficiency - two teenagers want food as quickly as possible so I can rattle off an order in record speed. The 17yo has lived in the US pretty much unaccompanied or with adults in his team so is completely able to handle ordering as is my husband however they just prefer to sit back and let me take control.
I don’t care if it’s called chilvary or good manners but being respectful is always to be practised for our family.
You are lucky
not to have that problem!
HI:
My feeling are similar to MGR's. I appreciate kindness, helpfulness, politeness and acts of goodwill. I sincerely appreciate when someone opens the door for me and always acknowledge that act of kindness. And I reciprocate with like behaviors.
My Mom was a stickler for manners. I never gave it a second thought to get up out of my seat for someone else. Or to open a door and say please and thank you. Or to help a Mom whose baby is crying when she is struggling with car seats and parcels. Which leads to a story.
When I was a teen, I went to the local grocer near my house. As I was walking in, an adult man was behind me, so I opened the door for him and let him walk in first. He thanked me, I smiled and said you're welcome. When I came out, he was there by his car with something in his hand. A business card. He approached me and stated he was very impressed by my behavior--polite and thoughtful--and these were the kind of traits he valued in an employee. He was the owner/manager of a service company and offered me a part time job. I was shocked. He gave me his card and encouraged me to follow up and he left. Of course I couldn't work for him as I as only 14--he didn't know that--but I'll never forget the interaction. My reverse chivalry (almost) landed me a job!!!
Also I experienced an act of great manners (or chivalry) this week while at the hospital. It is a busy place and people are always in a hurry and piling on top of each other in elevators and stairways. So as I was descending the stairwell, I noticed a young fella coming up and he gave me a big smile, stopped, and waited for me to go ahead. I smiled back and thanked him. He could have easily plowed by, as everyone else does everyday. Yanno, it's the little things that make such a difference. Good manners is like good grooming--can never have enough.
Fun thread.
cheers--Sharon
Your maiden name is just SOME OTHER GUYS NAME (your dad). Its literally based on the 'misogynistic' thing that the kid gets the dads last name.
So I am MUCH happier to take my husbands last name. I CHOSE my husband, it was MY decision, i picked him from every man on the earth, it wasnt just decided for me by someone else ... and I mean, at the end of the day, it's just some MANs last name
It is the little things that can make a big impact. A small act of kindness goes a long way. Unfortunately, an act of rudeness also goes far, if you let it. Some days, I have to mentally turn a corner so that I don't allow some else's rudeness get me in a bad mood. I would much rather spread kindness, then crabbiness.
Chivalry, etiquette, manners or common decency, whatever you want to call it seems to have gone by the wayside.
I was in a store on base one day trying on shoes, the aisle being extremely narrow and no bench to sit on as you put shoes on I was putting a shoe on and looking at others. A lady and her teenage daughter came through the aisle with her cart (she could have left it at the end of the aisle) forcing me to squeeze up next to the shoe rack. I didn't say anything. She went 2 rows over in shoes and I heard her say "she's just a retard that doesn't know how to get out of the way, I looked up and she was looking at me with a sneer and her daughter said "she heard you". I ignored her as I work for a department within the organization that has the shoe store and didn't want to get into a situation. I moved over to another shoe aisle and they were in a section nearby and she yells B!tch (her teenage daughter just smiling). I look up and she's looking at me. I mean she yelled it right there in a store with others and children around.
I figured, work aside, I am going to get security over here. I explained what happened and they pulled up the cameras and saw it. Shortly thereafter i heard a commotion and her shouting "my husband is an officer" as they were being directed out of the store.
Usually I would have had my say and it would have gotten ugly but I kept my cool as I work within the organization.
Hilarious that they got hustled out of the store though. I hope you waved to them!![]()