Help me decide which diamond!!! 1.7 or 1.56

[jessica2138]

Hello!

I have two diamond options to purchase. Please help me decide which one because I am stuck.


Option 1

• Round cut
• 1.7 carat
• G colour
• SI1 (eye clean but visible WHITE inclusions if you look hard enough, supplier said does not negatively affect diamonds performance)
• Has near perfect Hearts & Arrows
• Not milky, has no brown or yellow tints

Option 2

• Round cut
• 1.56 carat
• G colour
• VS2 (eye clean, in diamond video looks very clear and cant see any inclusions at all)
• Not sure about Hearts & Arrows
• Not milky, has no brown or yellow tints (in video overall white looking diamond)

Both are very similar in price so that isn't a deciding factor.

Will appreciate all the opinions I can get from experienced diamond experts and buyers!

Thank you!

 

[flyingpig]

Need some photos and videos and reports

 

[jessica2138]

Need some photos and videos and reports

This is the 1.7

I dont have an image of the 1.56

 

[tyty333]

Need GIA reports with angles...

Have you seen both of these stones? We havent!

You need to give us more information if you want help.

 

[LLJsmom]

It’s about the cut, as well as inclusions. And vendor can make a difference. More info can only be helpful.

 

[lovedogs]

We need the angles from the GIA report and any other pictures or videos you have. We can't help without that