- Joined
- Aug 14, 2009
- Messages
- 27,420
natyLad|1341828987|3230920 said:I guess i won't be very popular around here after posting this but i just have to say it...How come ALL the people who own SI2 diamonds and post here about them, claim that they are eye clean? I don't remember reading a thread about an SI2 diamond without seeing the "eye clean" comment inside a parenthesis. I don't doubt that there are some (very few) eye clean SI2's out there, but it seems that this rare species is found around these parts in great numbers...
Alright, go ahead, shoot me now...
Haha I've questioned the same things and I *am* one of those people! I think it really depends on where you get the stone. When a vendor like WF or GOG or BGD or HPD advertises a branded SI2 as eyeclean by whatever in-house definition I don't question it. I definitely agree that eyeclean SI2s on the virtual inventory are needles in the haystack though! Given how many opportunities tradepeople have to pick off the good ones before they get in front of the customer.
I currently have a 2.7 SI2 that is *not* eyeclean. The main (visible) inclusions are prongable, and when it's set properly it looks clean, and for me, that's all I care about. It's why I'm such a PITA w/ vendors about orienting it a certain way! It took two vendors pulling stones to find it and it was priced more like an SI1 but at the time there weren't any others with the proportions I wanted.. and honestly I doubted an SI1 w/ table inclusions or something would be clean once set anyway, so better the devil (or girdle-inclusions) you know, y'know? My old stone was a 2ct SI2 that really, honestly was eyeclean by my definition (clean at 5-6" face-up). It was also from the virtual inventory. But it had odd proportions, very high crown & shallow pav, and it was a GIA VG b/c of "thick" girdle, and I suspect that's why it made it so far - if it had been a GIA EX I'm certain it'd have been snatched up much earlier on the assembly line.
I would never advise a new customer to buy an SI2 over 1ct on the virtual inventory - way too much hassle with way too low odds off success!