Elegant
Brilliant_Rock
- Joined
- Jun 12, 2008
- Messages
- 835
okay Elegant...how much did your E-ring cost?Date: 1/24/2009 9:47:30 PM
Author:Elegant
I see BEAUTIFUL rings on this forum and ALWAYS wonder how much someone spent on their ring...you know, just out of curiosity and sometimes to get an idea of what I CAN''T have!Why not mention the price? Just wondering...is it taboo and why?
Ditto. I see people asking all the time, how much did that setting cost. Usually people give that info when asked. It''s pretty easy to know what a stone cost, but settings are all over the place price wise.Date: 1/24/2009 10:18:55 PM
Author: diamondseeker2006
I see people ask prices on here plenty of times, especially when it is something like a setting. Diamond prices are easily accessible with the search by cut tool or by looking on vendor sites. I think it is acceptable to ask, ''Would you mind giving me a ballpark idea of the price range of your setting?'' Some will happily tell you the exact amount and others will give a general figure. But rarely will someone say no!
Ditto, but I wonder Elegant were you asking why don't ppl mention the price if not asked?(as in, as part of their SMTR thread)? I don't think thats usually appropriate for an ering imho.Date: 1/24/2009 10:18:55 PM
Author: diamondseeker2006
I see people ask prices on here plenty of times, especially when it is something like a setting. Diamond prices are easily accessible with the search by cut tool or by looking on vendor sites. I think it is acceptable to ask, 'Would you mind giving me a ballpark idea of the price range of your setting?' Some will happily tell you the exact amount and others will give a general figure. But rarely will someone say no!
Easy... $0.00 ... I don't have one...THANKS DF!!!Date: 1/24/2009 9:55:28 PM
Author: Dancing Fire
okay Elegant...how much did your E-ring cost?Date: 1/24/2009 9:47:30 PM
Author:Elegant
I see BEAUTIFUL rings on this forum and ALWAYS wonder how much someone spent on their ring...you know, just out of curiosity and sometimes to get an idea of what I CAN'T have!Why not mention the price? Just wondering...is it taboo and why?
I understand what you are saying...kind of weird posting pics and all that and then writing GRAND TOTAL...Date: 1/24/2009 10:48:14 PM
Author: arjunajane
Date: 1/24/2009 10:18:55 PM
Author: diamondseeker2006
I see people ask prices on here plenty of times, especially when it is something like a setting. Diamond prices are easily accessible with the search by cut tool or by looking on vendor sites. I think it is acceptable to ask, 'Would you mind giving me a ballpark idea of the price range of your setting?' Some will happily tell you the exact amount and others will give a general figure. But rarely will someone say no!
Ditto, but I wonder Elegant were you asking why don't ppl mention the price if not asked?(as in, as part of their SMTR thread)? I don't think thats usually appropriate for an ering imho.
But I agree with the others, most things are easy enough to find out, or just politely ask the member.
Yeah, but at the same time some people get really good deals on diamonds or settings, and I don''t see anything wrong with listing the final price or price range. Maybe I can say this now because I don''t have one? But tons of people list specs but why not the price at the end?Date: 1/24/2009 10:18:55 PM
Author: diamondseeker2006
I see people ask prices on here plenty of times, especially when it is something like a setting. Diamond prices are easily accessible with the search by cut tool or by looking on vendor sites. I think it is acceptable to ask, ''Would you mind giving me a ballpark idea of the price range of your setting?'' Some will happily tell you the exact amount and others will give a general figure. But rarely will someone say no!
I''ve done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I''m sure most PSers don''t ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it''s pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn''t figure it out, I''d probably ask and tell them that of course they didn''t have to share if they didn''t want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn''t mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like ''WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?'' or are they asking because they''re dying to get one for themselves?
Date: 1/24/2009 11:12:23 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I''m sure most PSers don''t ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it''s pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn''t figure it out, I''d probably ask and tell them that of course they didn''t have to share if they didn''t want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn''t mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like ''WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?'' or are they asking because they''re dying to get one for themselves?
I''ve done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.
About treating the forum like real life, I would kind of disagree. I would NEVER ask someone how much their e-ring was, or any jewelry for that matter, but since this forum is here to show off our rings, jewels, and as a source of knowledge and reference, why not mention the price?
Seriously, I don't ask. I remember one of my friends telling me about the 2ct. diamond ring her fiancee gave her and I thought it was nice and complimented her and she voluntarily told me that the diamond itself cost $60,000 (probably paid too much but whatever, none of my business...).Date: 1/24/2009 11:32:24 PM
Author: thing2of2
Date: 1/24/2009 11:12:23 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I'm sure most PSers don't ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it's pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn't figure it out, I'd probably ask and tell them that of course they didn't have to share if they didn't want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn't mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like 'WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?' or are they asking because they're dying to get one for themselves?
I've done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.
About treating the forum like real life, I would kind of disagree. I would NEVER ask someone how much their e-ring was, or any jewelry for that matter, but since this forum is here to show off our rings, jewels, and as a source of knowledge and reference, why not mention the price?
Really? Well if you wouldn't ask in real life, why do you think people should share it here?
I would probably ask a good friend or close family member of mine how much a piece of jewelry was if I was interested in it for myself.
Well, after looking up your ring I think it is absolutely beautiful. I like knowing what, after finding the size and setting, and labor, what the finished product looks like because I am so out of touch with fine quality diamonds and jewelry. So looking at your ring and knowing the price and seeing the specs, etc. gives a great reference in my point of view.Date: 1/24/2009 11:37:33 PM
Author: AprilBaby
OK, I will just say it. My ring was $12,000. What does that tell you?
You are making a request in a round about way.... No one wants to say what their ring cost.. Online or in real life. It''s tacky to ask. I am fine with sharing how much I paid for a setting, but that''s about it.. JMHO. Ask away, see what people are willing to share with you, but asking about a ring, wow how much did that cost you, seems in poor taste to me. You can find the answer by pricescoping the stone and then adding a certain amount for the setting.Date: 1/24/2009 11:47:36 PM
Author: Elegant
Seriously, I don''t ask. I remember one of my friends telling me about the 2ct. diamond ring her fiancee gave her and I thought it was nice and complimented her and she voluntarily told me that the diamond itself cost $60,000 (probably paid too much but whatever, none of my business...).Date: 1/24/2009 11:32:24 PM
Author: thing2of2
Date: 1/24/2009 11:12:23 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I''m sure most PSers don''t ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it''s pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn''t figure it out, I''d probably ask and tell them that of course they didn''t have to share if they didn''t want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn''t mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like ''WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?'' or are they asking because they''re dying to get one for themselves?
I''ve done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.
About treating the forum like real life, I would kind of disagree. I would NEVER ask someone how much their e-ring was, or any jewelry for that matter, but since this forum is here to show off our rings, jewels, and as a source of knowledge and reference, why not mention the price?
Really? Well if you wouldn''t ask in real life, why do you think people should share it here?
I would probably ask a good friend or close family member of mine how much a piece of jewelry was if I was interested in it for myself.
Again, the reason I think people might want to - I never said should - share is for reference/knowledge - just what I think this forum is all about. It is sharing and learning, right?
And please don''t get mad at me...I am just merely asking a question, I am not making a request or anything.
That's why I posted this question - I just wanted opinions. So it is taboo - right? So thank you so much for kindly sharing your perspective and opinion on how giving the price is taboo - which was my original question. And for sharing that you would only give out the price of the setting - but my question also is why are you uncomfortable with sharing the price of it as a whole? I honestly don't understand, hence the question. You might think I am stupid or curt, and by your response it kind of sounds like you think I might be both...but again, hard to tell reading text and not hearing it from the person directly.Date: 1/25/2009 12:04:57 AM
Author: Kaleigh
You are making a request in a round about way.... No one wants to say what their ring cost.. Online or in real life. It's tacky to ask. I am fine with sharing how much I paid for a setting, but that's about it.. JMHO. Ask away, see what people are willing to share with you, but asking about a ring, wow how much did that cost you, seems in poor taste to me. You can find the answer by pricescoping the stone and then adding a certain amount for the setting.Date: 1/24/2009 11:47:36 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 11:32:24 PM
Author: thing2of2
Date: 1/24/2009 11:12:23 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I'm sure most PSers don't ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it's pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn't figure it out, I'd probably ask and tell them that of course they didn't have to share if they didn't want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn't mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like 'WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?' or are they asking because they're dying to get one for themselves?
I've done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.
About treating the forum like real life, I would kind of disagree. I would NEVER ask someone how much their e-ring was, or any jewelry for that matter, but since this forum is here to show off our rings, jewels, and as a source of knowledge and reference, why not mention the price?
Really? Well if you wouldn't ask in real life, why do you think people should share it here?
I would probably ask a good friend or close family member of mine how much a piece of jewelry was if I was interested in it for myself.
Seriously, I don't ask. I remember one of my friends telling me about the 2ct. diamond ring her fiancee gave her and I thought it was nice and complimented her and she voluntarily told me that the diamond itself cost $60,000 (probably paid too much but whatever, none of my business...).
Again, the reason I think people might want to - I never said should - share is for reference/knowledge - just what I think this forum is all about. It is sharing and learning, right?
And please don't get mad at me...I am just merely asking a question, I am not making a request or anything.
It is a good question. I tried to answer it from my perspective. I have been here for 4 years, have seen many questions asked. It's fine to ask, but just in the right way. Yanno? I meant no disrespect to you at all. If that's what you got from my post, I apologize. We all have different points of view...Date: 1/25/2009 12:15:30 AM
Author: Elegant
That's why I posted this question - I just wanted opinions. So it is taboo - right? So thank you so much for kindly sharing your perspective and opinion on how giving the price is taboo - which was my original question. And for sharing that you would only give out the price of the setting - but my question also is why are you uncomfortable with sharing the price of it as a whole? I honestly don't understand, hence the question. You might think I am stupid or curt, and by your response it kind of sounds like you think I might be both...but again, hard to tell reading text and not hearing it from the person directly.Date: 1/25/2009 12:04:57 AM
Author: Kaleigh
You are making a request in a round about way.... No one wants to say what their ring cost.. Online or in real life. It's tacky to ask. I am fine with sharing how much I paid for a setting, but that's about it.. JMHO. Ask away, see what people are willing to share with you, but asking about a ring, wow how much did that cost you, seems in poor taste to me. You can find the answer by pricescoping the stone and then adding a certain amount for the setting.Date: 1/24/2009 11:47:36 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 11:32:24 PM
Author: thing2of2
Date: 1/24/2009 11:12:23 PM
Author: Elegant
Date: 1/24/2009 10:04:59 PM
Author: thing2of2
I think most PSers treat PS like real life, and I'm sure most PSers don't ask or share the price of their jewelry in real life. Also, I think most of the time it's pretty easy to figure out how much something cost. You can search for similar diamonds, settings, etc. And if you *really* want something you could contact the vendor for a quote.
However, if I was desperate to know the price of something because I really wanted one myself and I couldn't figure it out, I'd probably ask and tell them that of course they didn't have to share if they didn't want to. And if someone asked me the price of something of mine because they wanted it for themselves, I wouldn't mind sharing.
It seems silly but I think intent of the asker also matters. Are they just being nosy, like 'WOW that must have cost a ton-how much was it?' or are they asking because they're dying to get one for themselves?
I've done that before, kind of saw something here and researched it. It did give me a price range. Easy enough, right? I agree.
About treating the forum like real life, I would kind of disagree. I would NEVER ask someone how much their e-ring was, or any jewelry for that matter, but since this forum is here to show off our rings, jewels, and as a source of knowledge and reference, why not mention the price?
Really? Well if you wouldn't ask in real life, why do you think people should share it here?
I would probably ask a good friend or close family member of mine how much a piece of jewelry was if I was interested in it for myself.
Seriously, I don't ask. I remember one of my friends telling me about the 2ct. diamond ring her fiancee gave her and I thought it was nice and complimented her and she voluntarily told me that the diamond itself cost $60,000 (probably paid too much but whatever, none of my business...).
Again, the reason I think people might want to - I never said should - share is for reference/knowledge - just what I think this forum is all about. It is sharing and learning, right?
And please don't get mad at me...I am just merely asking a question, I am not making a request or anything.
In all honesty, this is an innocent question with no manipulative preconceived purpose...believe it or not.
Well if there is a ring you love, you can say, I adore your ring. Do you mind sharing what the ball park figure is?Date: 1/25/2009 12:30:20 AM
Author: Elegant
Kaleigh - You said 'It's fine to ask, but just in the right way.' Do you mean ask an individual in an individual post - or that I asked wrong in this post?
Again, thanks for answering. I do appreciate it.
Pricescopers are generally a high class bunch, and etiquette dictates that you don''t go screaming in a thread "OMG, that is AWESOME! How much did you pay for that sucker?!"Date: 1/25/2009 2:29:11 AM
Author: Elegant
You know, I just spoke with bf and he told me it''s none of my ''f''ing business what people pay for their rings because it is private. And then we got into an argument over why I haven''t gotten my anniversary ring...ugh.
Plus, this isn''t a thread asking people to post prices, I was just wondering if it is taboo - because nobody seems to mention that...that''s all!
Thanks Kaleigh...from the sounds of it, I am an ass...
Exactly - I won''t ever ask, even in a nice enthusiastic way on here, even if I absolutely loved it because I think it is impolite to ask...I agree 100%.Date: 1/25/2009 2:59:53 AM
Author: Dancing Fire
this reminds me of a funny thread on a koi forum that i frequent...
a member posted a picture of a koi he just purchase. a newbie comes along and ask...how much did you paid for the fish? btw,just like on a diamond forum it would be consider very impolite to ask what others paid for a fish on a koi forum.
anyway, the guy replied to the newbie''s Q,he said...i paid $7500 for the fish,then the newbie replied to the owner of this $7500 koi and said...stop lyingthere''re no koi that expensive,i bet ya only paid $75 for that fishbtw; most of the forum members knew it was a $7500 fish or somewhere close to that amount.
i don''t think the newbie meant to be rude,but being a newbie in the hobby,he just didn''t realize there are many expensive koi out there.
okay Lisa, i adore your Tiff & Co ring. how much did hubby paid for your E-ring?Date: 1/25/2009 12:40:17 AM
Author: Kaleigh
Well if there is a ring you love, you can say, I adore your ring. Do you mind sharing what the ball park figure is?Date: 1/25/2009 12:30:20 AM
Author: Elegant
Kaleigh - You said ''It''s fine to ask, but just in the right way.'' Do you mean ask an individual in an individual post - or that I asked wrong in this post?
Again, thanks for answering. I do appreciate it.
Date: 1/25/2009 12:00:18 AM
Author: Elegant
Well, after looking up your ring I think it is absolutely beautiful. I like knowing what, after finding the size and setting, and labor, what the finished product looks like because I am so out of touch with fine quality diamonds and jewelry. So looking at your ring and knowing the price and seeing the specs, etc. gives a great reference in my point of view.
I posted a craptastic e-ring/w-ring set that I bought 14 years ago and said it was $160...10kt. gold, 3 stone, and I didn''t know the specs of the diamonds at all. Maybe it was because it was so cheap that it doesn''t matter how much it costs.