Is this emerald too light?

[RRfromR]

It came back from GIA as untreated/no oil and the diamond quality is excellent. I'm used to very bright colored emeralds, so I need a sanity check.

 

[musicloveranthony]

Those are beautiful. They look like the untreated emeralds I bought in Colombia

 

[mellowyellowgirl]

For me yes but they are quite pretty! I've been looking around at emeralds and have seen lighter than these so they are not the lightest!

 

[RRfromR]

Those are beautiful. They look like the untreated emeralds I bought in Colombia

@musicloveranthony , yes, they are Muzo

 

[T L]

They’re on the lighter side, but I would still qualify them as emeralds, not green beryl (a very pale green).

Very pretty!

 

[RRfromR]

Hi all, so I decided to return it only because I'm thinking of doing a custom project with the seller. This is the stone I got - 0.58 ct, untreated / no oil.
If anyone wants this original 3 stones one - let me know and I'll post the seller name - I'm not affiliated. It went to gia in Carlsbad who confirmed that it is earth mined diamond, 0.37 ct, VVS and G and the emeralds are untreated, no oil, 0.54 tcw. It was around $1300. I wanted to keep it because I love the diamond, but can't do both.