Need opinions on this Round 1.84 G VS2 stone - pls help!

[lovedogs]

my jeweler friend inspected the stone and rejected it only because of the mixed tinge. otherwise its a good stone . But , he said he would not buy it.

I now have two more choices.


1.8 G VVS2 by IGI - HCA 2.9 VG, VG, G ,G - $9100
(https://ds-360.jaykar.co.in/ds_360.php?chk=QWxs&q=SllLMTdKMjMxMDc1LVA=0) Friend saw it and said its a good stone - more like a decent GIA and is saying its a good option

1.81 H VS2 GIA - HCA 1.8, VG, EX, VG, VG - $10,200 (above my ideal budget of $9000) - My friend has not seen this physically yet
Video and ASET images : http://app.dnavin.com/Account/dnapage?PacketNo=50174

Both Certs attached...

Really appreciate all you guys' help here!

The 1.81 has potential

 

[ayushkhatri]

The 1.81 has potential

yea but its more than what I would ideally like to pay ....its a waste off money in my opinion with no resale value so im looking for a good stone with bang for my buck.

any idea why the mixed tinge would be bad? its a 1.7 GIA h VS1 with HCA 2.5 for 8230$

 

[freddyboston]

Glowy Raves are the Only kind i buy.... i have a theory in few years they'll be appreciated more + sell at a premium...

 

[freddyboston]

yea but its more than what I would ideally like to pay ....its a waste off money in my opinion with no resale value so im looking for a good stone with bang for my buck.

any idea why the mixed tinge would be bad? its a 1.7 GIA h VS1 with HCA 2.5 for 8230$

mixed tinge means not just yellow - could be brown, green or gray... the market discounts $ them and they are harder to sell etc...... on the other hand, some people claim the brown tinted can look whiter face up than the yellows so you could save $ if you like how it looks....