Please help me choose between these two diamonds!

[Echob]

Hi all,

I am trying to decide between two diamonds and would like your thoughts. It is for an engagement ring. Thank you in advance for sharing your opinions and knowledge with me.

1. 0.713 CT, F, VVS1.
HCA score: 0.6, "big"
AGS report: attached (Screenshot_20210206-091333__01.jpg)
Image of diamond from video:
(Screenshot_20210206-091305__01.jpg)
Price: $4,040 USD



2. 0.703 CT, F, VS1
HCA score: 1.2, "big"
AGS report: attached
Image of diamond from video: attached
Price: $3,826 USD

 

[lovedogs]

You cant go wrong with an ACA and both of these look beautiful.

 

[jp201845]

I would go with the second one VVS1 is overkill and you are paying the premium for something you can’t see .

 

[Dididudu16]

I’m not expert but I think both are very beautiful. I would pick the first one since I think it’s worth it to pay additional $200 for a vvs1 clarity between these two diamonds. I also like the first one with slightly smaller table. But that’s just me. Good Luck!

 

[jp201845]

I’m not expert but I think both are very beautiful. I would pick the first one since I think it’s worth it to pay additional $200 for a vvs1 clarity between these two diamonds. I also like the first one with slightly smaller table. But that’s just me. Good Luck!

I think the proportions are better on the second stone but thats just me....

 

[LLJsmom]

I would choose #2 cause I think generally I would prefer a bigger table and larger LGF. Both at every safe choices though.