Poll: Help choosing anniversary ring

[Lizika]

On the left is a 1.5ct, on the right is 2ct. I like the bigger finger coverage on the left even though the carat weight is lower. The stones also appear a little whiter to me though both rings are supposed to be I, VS2.
I am completely unable to make a decision here. Which would you go with as a right-hand ring??
Thanks!!

 

[Lizika]

Here’s a better picture of the sparkle...

 

[missy]

I like the ring on the left. Makes more of an impact and I like the width better.

 

[Taylorbug!]

Do you have a profile picture?

 

[partgypsy]

by far the one on the right better.

 

[Bluegemz]

I vote for the right! How exciting!

 

[Lizika]

Of course opinions are evenly split. That’s exactly how I feel
I didn’t choose my engagement ring so I’m enjoying the fact that I get to pick this one. I didn’t expect to be so torn!
Thanks for your input.