shape
carat
color
clarity

Update!! I had the talk about meeting both our needs re. the ring budget!

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

winternight

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Nov 12, 2006
Messages
887
Thanks to everyone who has given me such great advice and support! What an amazing group!

Last night, being impatient, I talked to my fiance about the wedding reception - I told him that since it seemed important to him we''d do it and he needed to start thinking about what he wanted so that I could start the research (I''m usually the researcher with things). I told him that I was looking into ways to save money - i.e. holding it a little off season - but some things - open bar - were going to be expensive and that was ok. I really would have prefered a more low-key approach, but its important to him.

On to the main event, the ring discussion, I told him that I had good news and bad news about the ring, he asked for the bad first. I said that while I wanted to keep looking I really think that the 1.1 ct ring from Tiffany was simple, elegant, and I''d like to see it again to see how it sparkles (in the daytime, we went at night). I told him that I want an amazing ring no matter what (I blame you guys!).

He was a little surprised b/c of the price but then I told him the good news, that I had found a site (store in NYC) signedpieces.com (based on that gorgous ring posted the other day in show me your ring) that sold Tiffany solitaires and other rings at a substantial discount to retail - why b/c they were ''used'' and honestly I could care less about that. He wanted to maybe look the next time we were in NYC but maybe if we look at some retail stores a bit more, Tiffany and some others, he''ll be more comfortable ordering online. We could perhaps also ask them to hold a ring and do a weekend trip to NYC - that would be fun!

I think he''s going on the assumption that he may have to pay 10-13k and I think that''s probably better for both of us. I felt really guilty about it and told him so and his response was ''don''t worry about it.'' Repeatedly. Have to say I love the guy! I did also point out that I was willing to do the reception b/c that was what he wanted. All in all it was really easy, I feel a little spoiled and a little guilty. But I think its important that I''m happy b/c I don''t want to start out worrying about the ''upgrade.''

Again thanks and I''ll keep posting as we search and when we find the ring! We may hold off, not because he wants to, but because I know he''s looking at a job change and would be more comfortable if that was out of the way before a big purchase. Besides he''ll be making more money, no doubt, at the new job so I think the price shock will also be less.
 
I think this is awesome and I DO think you should do a weekend trip to NYC and while you''re there you MUST go visit jon at good od gold - tell him to have at least one superideal 1 carat there and then let your *eyes* do the choosing rather than what is convenient or what you know ie brand name. good luck!!
 
that''s great winter!! I was sure everything was going to work out fine.. you seem to have a guy who loves to make you happy and that''s what he''ll always do.. congratulations!!

I can''t wait for you to start your search!!
36.gif
 
I''m so glad you guys had such a productive conversation!
36.gif
Now ring searching will be fun as opposed to stressful, yippee!

I followed your other thread w/o commenting and asked my husband what he thought because so many men''s comments were negative. He felt that you should get the ring of your choice considering the circumstances, so there is another male on your side.
 
That is great! Sometimes we worr and stress about stuff and it is really not as bad as we think once we approach it in a calm way. I am glad he was able to see that and be open to the conversation! Congrats and good luck. Just to let you know when I broached the subject of an upgrade for my 40th and our 15th anniversary, I think I mentioned it in March, and by June 1 I had it, and had more than I expected. I seriously never thought he would be fine with it and support it and I kept working myself up, and then one day I just blurted out what I wanted and he seemed a bit taken aback but then he was on board. So I think sometimes we really anticipate things happening differently and we get upset or stressed needlessly...
 
Date: 11/16/2006 10:42:29 AM
Author: KimberlyH
I''m so glad you guys had such a productive conversation!
36.gif
Now ring searching will be fun as opposed to stressful, yippee!

I followed your other thread w/o commenting and asked my husband what he thought because so many men''s comments were negative. He felt that you should get the ring of your choice considering the circumstances, so there is another male on your side.
Your''s is obvously a keeper.
28.gif
 
ah, the power of conversation and compromise!

good start for a marriage!

movie zombie
 
YAY for you guys!!! sometimes the thought of communication scares us but then it goes wonderfully and you feel silly for having worried at all. these men are our mates for life after all, chances are they understand us better than we think!
9.gif
please do keep us posted and i would definitely check out as much as possible before buying, esp if you go into NYC. there are two jewelers i would definitely check out there other than SP. GOG and SuperbCert. they both carry exceptionally cut stones and have a fair amount of inventory. so hopefully between SP, Tiffany, GOG and SC you''ll be well-educated to make a smart and beautiful decision. good luck!
 
That''s awesome, so happy for you two!! I think a trip to NYC will be great. Make sure to get out to GOG as well. It''s an hour''s train ride from the city.
 
Date: 11/16/2006 10:46:05 AM
Author: winternight

Date: 11/16/2006 10:42:29 AM
Author: KimberlyH
I''m so glad you guys had such a productive conversation!
36.gif
Now ring searching will be fun as opposed to stressful, yippee!

I followed your other thread w/o commenting and asked my husband what he thought because so many men''s comments were negative. He felt that you should get the ring of your choice considering the circumstances, so there is another male on your side.
Your''s is obvously a keeper.
28.gif
As is yours!!!
 
that is great news winter...i hope you find your dream ring
1.gif
 
That''s great news! And a good way to start off. I am sure you''ll find exactly what you want and are going into the search with so much more information than the average shopper. Keep us posted on what you find. We love success stories!!
 
Some honest conversation and compromising goes a long way, doesn''t it? Yay for you, both of you!
36.gif
9.gif
 
I didn''t read through your whole thread but I wanted to see what the outcome was because my situation was very similar to yours. I am very happy to hear that it all turned out good. It just makes things start out happy instead of with angst and frustration.

Can''t wait to hear about your search. You KNOW you have to tell us all about it. :)
 
I''m so glad to hear this, Winter!!! I had a feeling it''d turn out OK, since in your other thread you described a man who was just totally unfamiliar with the whole bling thing....and not a cheap guy by nature. It''s funny how we women are reluctant to open up to our husbands about our love of bling -- when I first told my DH in early 2005 that I wanted a larger stone, his response was, "I had no idea you even liked jewelry!" Well, that was cuz I''d always kept it to myself, afraid of what he''d think of me. Now he definitely knows!
emembarrassed.gif
And he still loves me, woohoo. Like others have said, this bodes well for your marriage so far. Opening up and trying to understand each other....it''s a great thing.
emteeth.gif
 
~~Winter, I''m so glad that things worked out for you...secretly, I knew that they would!!
2.gif
I really hope that you are able to find the ring of your dreams!!!
 
Fantastic, I am glad you guys are able to communicate so well! (one day you will be laughing about this! - probably round about the time you get your 5 carat upgrade
31.gif
) Haha!

I ''34th'' the recommendation to go to GOG while in NY to get the education with him - SP can be a great deal if they have what you want, but definitely go to GOG with him - the education itself will be worth it for both of you!
 
Do NOT miss out on going to Good Old Gold on Long Island, or at least visiting on line. You will get a better, bigger stone there than at Tiffany''s for a lot less money. You might even get back down close to his original range. Heck, splurge on the setting some to make up for not having a Tiffany''s ring, and you''ll still be many $1,000''s ahead.
 
Congrats on your talk, it looks like it went well. I really doubt he was dead set on 6k anyways -- I think sometimes when guys first go look they have a price in their head, and that doesn''t necessarily reflect the ring they have in mind -- most guys probably aren''t quite sure how much engagement rings cost, and how much of a ring they can get for the price in their head. Since money doesn''t seem like a huge limiting factor in your relationship given your good salaries and low debt, his "budget" was likely a case of not really knowing tons and tons about jewelry prices. It''s good that you nudged him in the right direction
1.gif
 
Congrats! Communication and compromise are key to a good and lasting marriage. When he sees how much crap costs for a wedding, he''s not even gonna stress that much over the ring anymore. Especially once the wedding is over. Just make sure to gush over your ring periodically to him to make him feel good about getting you the ring.
 
Yes! I had a feeling it would turn out like this! Okay, here's about the 37th recommendation...we got a gorgeous stone from Jonathan at Good Old Gold, too, and I can't say enough about what a great person he is...plus he picks great diamonds, too!
2.gif


I'd for sure love a Tiffany from Signed Pieces and look on there often. But I will tell you that GOG's diamonds are often better. However, we're talking about excellent stones overall at both...ideal versus super-ideal.

ETA: Good Old Gold is a real jewelry store, by the way, not just an online presence.
 
go get ''em, tiger!
 
Glad you guys are communicating your expectations and everything works out great. That''s the best thing to do; no guessing what he is thinking. Now you can really get started with the researching and shopping, and have fun.
 
Sounds like a great conversation for both of you... so glad things are working out, Winter!!!
36.gif
 
A great outcome, now you can progress forward and get your ring soon.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top