Which diamond necklace do you pick?

[Holls0119]

Which diamond do you pick (these are Tiffany I like the way they do their setting, but I know it’s more expensive)

Top: .44, Color G, VS1, $4,210
Bottom: .47, Color H, VVS1, $4,680


Here are three selections:
Top: .44, Color G, VS1, $4,210
Middle: .42 Color H, VS1, $3,670
Bottom: .47, Color H, VVS1, $4,680

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Are the stones graded by GIA? I can't tell much, if any, difference in the pictures, but I might have a preference of one stone over the other depending on the cut and diameter.

 

[Holls0119]

These are Tiffany so they do their in house report. I normally would go with GIA over an in house Tiffany report and build my own necklace for the price. But I really just like the rose gold setting and how they do the Elsa Peretti necklace.

 

[daisygrl]

Not knowing absolutely anything about the stones except the color/carat/and clarity, I would go with the smallest one. H, VS1 is fine for its size and for a necklace - it is the most reasonably priced and the size difference is miniscule. There will be no difference between G and H in this size combined with a rose gold setting. VVS1 is an overkill.

 

[distracts]

I like the biggest one and think it looks noticeably bigger than the others.

 

[oncrutchesrightnow]

I think the 0.44 is the sparkliest but it is hard to tell cut without lab reports.

 

[goldnsilver]

I was also more drawn to the 0.44 in the first photo, but yeah it's impossible to know for sure without lab reports or at least more close-up photos and videos.

I think the 0.47 is looking visibly larger more because it's closest to the camera?

 

[AprilBaby]

The .44 G

 

[Holls0119]

Thank you everyone I did end up going to the store yesterday. I picked the .47 H. When it was in a line up or I tried it on, I kept gravitating to that one even when not told which stone was which. To me the .47 sparkled more in person. Hope I didn’t make a mistake. I’m sure it will be lovely no matter what.

 

[meesmom]

Thank you everyone I did end up going to the store yesterday. I picked the .47 H. When it was in a line up or I tried it on, I kept gravitating to that one even when not told which stone was which. To me the .47 sparkled more in person. Hope I didn’t make a mistake. I’m sure it will be lovely no matter what.

Its beautiful!!! I agree, there is nothing like the original elsa peretti setting. I have 3 tiffany dbty necklaces, and i love them all. Show some modeling pics please??

 

[OdetteOdile]

I love the Elsa Peretti dbty too! This same necklace is on my wish list. I think if your eyes kept returning to the same diamond/necklace again and again there is no way you made a mistake. Enjoy your gorgeous necklace!!

 

[goldnsilver]

That's wonderful you were able to make your choice! Hope it brings you much joy wearing it. Neck photo soon please.

 

[RunningwithScissors]

Enjoy! These are all lovely!

 

[Holls0119]

Thank you! I can’t wait to get the necklace back it has been sent off to extend the chain from 16 inches to 17 inches. I will post a picture as soon as I pick it up (they said about 3 weeks).

 

[Holls0119]

Which diamond do you pick (these are Tiffany I like the way they do their setting, but I know it’s more expensive)

Top: .44, Color G, VS1, $4,210
Bottom: .47, Color H, VVS1, $4,680


Here are three selections:
Top: .44, Color G, VS1, $4,210
Middle: .42 Color H, VS1, $3,670
Bottom: .47, Color H, VVS1, $4,680

Thank you! I can’t wait to get the necklace back it has been sent off to extend the chain from 16 inches to 17 inches. I will post a picture as soon as I pick it up (they said about 3 weeks).

Here she is…

 

[meesmom]

Here she is…

Wow!! Very beautiful!!! Congratulations!!

 

[OdetteOdile]

Perfection!!

 

[oncrutchesrightnow]

How pretty!