shape
carat
color
clarity

3 carat round diamond

Screenshot_20221128-223036_Chrome.jpg
so any of these are good for TH? 1.5 there are 2 choices. Are they both equally good? So 3 carat I color won't be yellow warm and by happy for thr size and color?

I am confused. What size do you want? What is your budget? The choices you linked are all different in terms of cost, suze, and color
 
Screenshot_20221128-224902_Samsung Internet.jpg
Do you think this 2.53 f is better than the 3 carat I color from WH?
Here are some size comps on a size 5 finger for you. The 2 ct versus the 3 ct and the 2.5 versus the 3.01 ct.

Is there any chance that your girlfriend will want to upgrade in the future?
If so, maybe you should consider this F color stone. You will be guaranteed to get the best light performance (the GIA F you linked maybe a bit cheaper due to the fluoro). If you want the GIA F, you need to vet the cut by getting ASET images etc.


C280EA3E-50CC-470C-A1D3-7196150F483B.jpeg

3368B7B3-F72C-432C-8F98-04F4F81655A9.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Here are some size comps on a size 5 finger for you. The 2 ct versus the 3 ct and the 2.5 versus the 3.01 ct.

Is there any chance that your girlfriend will want to upgrade in the future?
If so, maybe you should consider this F color stone. You will be guaranteed to get the best light performance (the GIA F you linked maybe a bit cheaper due to the fluoro). If you want the GIA F, you need to vet the cut by getting ASET images etc.


C280EA3E-50CC-470C-A1D3-7196150F483B.jpeg

3368B7B3-F72C-432C-8F98-04F4F81655A9.jpeg

Thank you for the images. What about this True heart f color compared to the other 2.53 Th?Screenshot_20221129-122359_Samsung Internet.jpg
 
Thank you for the images. What about this True heart f color compared to the other 2.53 Th?Screenshot_20221129-122359_Samsung Internet.jpg

You need to get advanced images-ASET and Idealscope. I just saw another Astor/ Hearts & Arrows ASET which was a mess.

I still don’t know how this one got an Astor designation:

D0011163-F09A-4FA7-919C-BAE04887100D.jpeg
 
So not good.
 
I am confused. What size do you want? What is your budget? The choices you linked are all different in terms of cost, suze, and color

Yes, can you clarify what size and budget we should be helping you look for?
 
Screenshot_20221129-184214_Samsung Internet.jpg
Here is the image for 2.52 for True Heart. Is the scope shows flaw in the TH cut?I have different size of TH on the list because they don't have much good selection for True Heart between 2.2 to 3 carat.
 
Is this another IGI certed stone? This would likely grade as an H or I color with GIA. Is this stone priced like a H/I color?

45,000 for the 3 carat G color
 
Screenshot_20221129-200317_Samsung Internet.jpgScreenshot_20221129-200320_Samsung Internet.jpg
Here thr 2.53 f color image images vs the images earlier is for 2.52 f color. 2 different loose diamond. Any preference which one the best?
 
Do you have links to videos of both stones?
 
@Kim N @DejaWiz @lovedogs

Thoughts?


It's a beautiful stone! I still really like the 2.498 F VS2 that you posted earlier from Whiteflash.

jstorm, as lulu_ma said, if there's any chance your partner might upgrade in the future, Whiteflash's upgrade policy is much better than James Allen's.
 
@Kim N @DejaWiz @lovedogs

Thoughts?


I feel that these represent a much better overall value for the overall package of:

1. Custom cut
2. Human vetted
3. Amazing lifetime upgrade program
4. Pinnacle of MRB/RBC optical performance
5. Same price realm



Look at those puffy crown heights!
 
It's a beautiful stone! I still really like the 2.498 F VS2 that you posted earlier from Whiteflash.

jstorm, as lulu_ma said, if there's any chance your partner might upgrade in the future, Whiteflash's upgrade policy is much better than James Allen's.

Can you send the link for the 2.498 f white flash again?
 
Can you send the link for the 2.498 f white flash again?

One post up...there's two to pick from. :)
Put them on hold/reserve as soon as possible so someone else doesn't buy them before you get a chance to decide which one you want.
 
I feel that these represent a much better overall value for the overall package of:

1. Custom cut
2. Human vetted
3. Amazing lifetime upgrade program
4. Pinnacle of MRB/RBC optical performance
5. Same price realm



Look at those puffy crown heights!

The 2.498 looks much cleaner than the 2.448. Amazing proportions on both of them!
 
The 2.498 looks much cleaner than the 2.448. Amazing proportions on both of them!

I agree...I'd be happy with either, but a little more happier with the 2.498!
 
You need to get advanced images-ASET and Idealscope. I just saw another Astor/ Hearts & Arrows ASET which was a mess.

I still don’t know how this one got an Astor designation:

D0011163-F09A-4FA7-919C-BAE04887100D.jpeg
Please no.
 
I feel that these represent a much better overall value for the overall package of:

1. Custom cut
2. Human vetted
3. Amazing lifetime upgrade program
4. Pinnacle of MRB/RBC optical performance
5. Same price realm



Look at those puffy crown heights!

Thank you @DejaWiz. @jstorm please follow the recommendations of the PSers. They have made wonderful suggestions. I love the two here and the 2.95 I from WF.
 
Yes. The 2.53 round True heart aset showed light leakage?

See 2 carat I color true heart. See attach image. Thoughts ?Screenshot_20221211-143725_Samsung Internet.jpg
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top