I loved most of the items on the initial list, but I am a food-loving, unpicky omnivore. I don''t see a lot of items that are "meat and potatoes" friendly.
I think you will do MUCH better with the buffet - that way people can pick what they like, you get more choice, and they can sample items that they would not feel comfortable ordering full on.
Where and when is this shindig? That will affect things. I would really recommend going with one of the cheesy pasta dishes (the fusilli sounds awesome and hearty, or a more traditional lasagna would be safe). Corn cakes also sound good, but spicy is not for everyone.
I think you will do MUCH better with the buffet - that way people can pick what they like, you get more choice, and they can sample items that they would not feel comfortable ordering full on.
Where and when is this shindig? That will affect things. I would really recommend going with one of the cheesy pasta dishes (the fusilli sounds awesome and hearty, or a more traditional lasagna would be safe). Corn cakes also sound good, but spicy is not for everyone.