Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

It''s between these two dresses...the Becca and the Rosette dress. Please help!

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
#1 the Becca - handsdown! I LOVE IT
 
I vote for the Becca!
 
#1 -- is that the Becca? It is beyond stunning on you. I love the empire waist sash and the detailing at the bottom of the dress, just gorgeous.
 
Becca! I love the details. I also think the overall design is more organic -- the pieces fit together and flow, while from the pictures, at least, the rosette looks a little more like elements thrown together. But-- you''d look lovely in either one!
 
Becca! Becca!
 
Thank you everyone!!! Sounds like the MAJORITY are for Becca. Me too!! The one catch is that my sister in law has SO generously offerered to buy my dress for me as a wedding gift to me. Yes, she''s unbelievable!!! I flew to NYC this weekend and the second dress was the one we found together (not the Becca). It is less expensive than the Becca by $1000. Do you think I should feel as though I should go with the second dress because it''s the one we found together and is less $$? She''d hasn''t even seen the BEcca on me. Just wondering what you think...

-Brightie
 
What if you offered to split the difference of the excess amount?

ETA: Will you see her around the holidays? Maybe you all could go look at the Becca then.
 
$1000 is a lot....BUT.....BECCA IS ABSOLUTELY BREATHTAKING ON YOU!

my jaw dropped to the ground when i scrolled through those pictures. it fits like a dream and the details are just perfect!! if the $1000 won''t completely burn a hole in your wallet...i''d TOTALLY go for it!

amazinggg!
30.gif
36.gif
30.gif
36.gif
30.gif
 
Definitely Becca - no contest! I'd offer to split the cost with your sister; the Becca is that much better.
 
I like Becca better. Both are great choices, but I think the trimming and lace on the Becca are a bit better.
 
Becca!
 
The first one.
 
Date: 11/19/2008 4:47:11 PM
Author: meresal
What if you offered to split the difference of the excess amount?


ETA: Will you see her around the holidays? Maybe you all could go look at the Becca then.
Click to expand...

That''s a good idea. I definitely will do that!!

The hard thing about making a decision from these photos was that the lighting in the second dress place was so much worse and the photos aren''t as clear and well framed. I wish I had been able to try both dresses at the same time, in the same store, and not 1000 miles apart from each other in very different lighting. I may try to get the second dress sent down here so I can do just that! Crazy me :-)
26.gif
 
Date: 11/19/2008 5:49:39 PM
Author: brightstone
The hard thing about making a decision from these photos was that the lighting in the second dress place was so much worse and the photos aren't as clear and well framed. I wish I had been able to try both dresses at the same time, in the same store, and not 1000 miles apart from each other in very different lighting. I may try to get the second dress sent down here so I can do just that! Crazy me :-)
26.gif
Click to expand...

No harm in trying, but IMHO, it's the dress, not the lighting. I prefer the fabric and the detailing of the Becca SO much more than the Rosette. I don't like the big flower in the middle of the Rosette, and I don't like how the hem of the Rosette is "unfinished" appearing. The Becca also seems to define your waist in a more flattering way, not that you need it! Overall, I think the Becca just looks a lot more sophisticated.
 
my vote is for becca....it looks amazing on you!
 
100% Becca. It looks amazing on you.
 
#1 - looks just fab on you!
 
There is no competition! Becca for sure. The detail and the fit on the Becca is incredible and breathtaking. The other dress is cute but not half as nice.
 
Definitely the Becca...I love the line of the dress...
 
HI:

Both stunning and fabu on you--but if push came to shove I''d probably say.....#1. It really made me ohh and ahh...

cheers--Sharon
 
Becca, number one all the way! You look amazing in it
 
Wow!! Tough choice... you look fabulous in both dresses. I think it comes down to the details and fabric since both dresses are just about the same shape. I think I''m siding just a tiny bit more with the Becca although I''ve always adored CH''s designs. Either way... they are both beautiful on you!!
 
No question, the Becca. Gorgeous.
 
I usually like CH better than Melissa Sweet. But I think you you look stunning in the Becca. The Rosette dress looks good on you, but I think the Becca looks better.
 
Date: 11/19/2008 12:46:20 PM
Author: brightstone
becca
Click to expand...
This is dress is so perfect on you, so beautiful, so lovely -- why look at anything else? This is absolutely stunning in its simplicity, its details, and the way it seems to just ''flow'' over your figure. Your hubby-to-be will be overcome with emotion when he sees you in ''Becca''.

Trust our reactions . . . . we all kind of said "WOW" when we saw the pictures of you in this dress. And you aren''t even all dolled up for the big event! Imagine what your friends and family, and FI will think.
 
No question for me - I love the Becca!!!
 
Ohhh..you are so pretty in both, but i LOVE the becca!
 
I would say the Becca, I am not a fan of the broach/clasp thing on the second one. I am usually not a fan of flowers or anything but I think the bottom of the becca is stunning! So classy and elegant
 
Another vote for Becca. Everything about that gown is just gorgeous!
36.gif
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top