- Joined
- Feb 27, 2007
- Messages
- 26,553
IndyLady said:The saga continues! The journey to a pad, an epic adventure indeed!
ETA: Ok, ok, I realize that I'm a troublemaker..could it be Platnetary Gems? Feel free to tell me that I'm wrong, or that its none of my business!
Nashville said:Returned the pad. It was unheated, but the color just wasn't there. And I am attached now to the idea of owning a padparadscha, not just a pink or orange sapphire.
tourmaline_lover said:Nashville said:Returned the pad. It was unheated, but the color just wasn't there. And I am attached now to the idea of owning a padparadscha, not just a pink or orange sapphire.
Do you want a padapradscha because of the marketing name and the fact that it's a sapphire (which in of itself is marketed more highly than other gems). Or do you like the stone because you like the pink-orange color?
You do realize that spinels can come in the same color as padparadscha for substantially less, and they are untreated. However, if you have your hopes set on a padparadscha sapphire, that's a different story.
TravelingGal said:pad hunts are messy...not sure I would do it again. In fact, I'm sure I wouldn't!
The stone looked pretty, sorry it didn't work out! Padparadscha is so so so hard to photograph, so I feel your pain.
As a pad owner, I'd ask you, do you for SURE have your heart set on one? I love the stone for the ring I made for my daughter. And because of what I went through (and Richard Wise being an up and up kind of guy) I got it for a good price. But I will admit, I wonder from time to time what my money would have gotten me if I decided to go for a less elusive (and iffily - if that's a word - marketed stone.) I love my ring because it's simple, subtle and very wearable. But it isn't going to wow anyone...pretty much only you will know what a padparadscha is, and I think a lot of people do want people to admire their engagement rings.
Also, for the average budget, it's hard to afford that "perfect" pad color, whatever that is. I love the color of my stone...it's always changing and surprising me. I still stare at it trying to determine its personality and I've had it for over a year now. Sometimes it's pale pink with a tinge of orange. Other times it's salmon. Other times it's sunset orange. I didn't use to see any modifiers in it, but now in certain lighting, my eyes can detect small amounts of brown. But it's so hard to say, because in a flash, I just don't see it anymore.
My point is, a pad will usually keep you guessing. Sometimes I wonder what I really have in my posession, even though it is certed by a reputable lab as an untreated padparadscha. Maybe another lab would call it something else.
A lot of people around here go on about how a pad is a marketing term and you are overpaying. And I think that is true...you WILL be paying a premium if you buy a pinkish orange sapphire labeled padparadscha. So good that you are getting certed and hopefully someone trustworthy is helping you on your hunt. But I do think if you loved the color of this stone, you should have kept it, because it seemed very pretty and I think it would be even better to get a "padish" color for a great price. Why do you actually need the certification and the name that goes along with pad? Because if you do, you are subscribing to the marketing.
I can understand, because I wanted something unique for my daughter's ring. I also wanted it to be unheated. But I can say that I sure would have loved to get a color I loved (namely, the stone I have) at a "regular" sapphire price if that meant the price was substantially lower than what I paid.
Sorry for the ramble...good luck!
iLander said:You should buy exactly what you like and nothing less. You'll be the one living with it.
I came across this stone, maybe it will work for you:
http://cgi.ebay.com/USA-CUT-RARE-UNTREA ... 197wt_1139
I think it's gorgeous, but too small for me.
I think this seller has been mentioned before on pricescope, but not sure . . .
crasru said:Nashville, have you ever seen a padparacha? It happened to me a couple of times, when I was chasing "a name", not a stone. And it is one thing to buy a spinel which is still pretty affordable than to invest into a more expensive stone which saturation and color may not be too well seen on the Internet monitor? And all pics of padparachas that I have seen here left me unmoved for one reason - I suspect it is hard to appreciate the color of a lightly saturated stone. I saw Weblorn's stone and she is a wonderful seller... but I would have passed on it. Until iLander pointed it out.
If I wanted a pad, I'd try to see them first at a trade show. I can not give you advices, of course, but the color seems to be too elusive.
ededdeddy said:To me this looked like a pad and it sold but the GIT cert calls it a pinkish orange, in that sense I do appreciate that the lab made the distinction that it wasn't a pad.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... 0487229450
Nashville said:ededdeddy said:To me this looked like a pad and it sold but the GIT cert calls it a pinkish orange, in that sense I do appreciate that the lab made the distinction that it wasn't a pad.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?Vi ... 0487229450
Yeah, it is definitely pretty. From what I understand pads are supposed to have little to no brown, but I could be wrong as the definition is so varied.
LovingDiamonds said:Oh Nashville I'm sorry things haven't turned out for you. For what it's worth, I actually really liked the colour of your gem - for me, a Pad has to have that delicate colourway but I can understand how it can lack "ooomph". I've got one very similar (a little more saturated than yours) that I love, but any lighter I'm not sure it would have stood the test of time. I'm totally with you on the trilliant! Love the colour but the cut is bleurgh!
Take your time and you can bet when you stop looking, one will fall in your lap!
By the way, if you have bought from Planetary Gems, it would be helpful to do a review if you have the time/inclination. I've been so tempted on many occasions to buy from them but I think there's only Arcadian(?) and Indy(?) who have had experience of them. I've sent them so many emails but they regularly ignore me so I've given up with them now!
tourmaline_lover said:Maybe I haven't seen a top color one yet, and even if it were top color, according to the labs it would have to be desaturated, which makes absolutely no sense to me as to why the trade values them so much.
You see, you (anyone, not just Nashville) might like desaturated orange-pink stones and that's fine, I respect that. However, in the trade, most gems are valued based on their saturation of color, so to pay a significant premium for a desaturated stone (dark toned aqua is another example), makes no sense to me.
TravelingGal said:tourmaline_lover said:Maybe I haven't seen a top color one yet, and even if it were top color, according to the labs it would have to be desaturated, which makes absolutely no sense to me as to why the trade values them so much.
You see, you (anyone, not just Nashville) might like desaturated orange-pink stones and that's fine, I respect that. However, in the trade, most gems are valued based on their saturation of color, so to pay a significant premium for a desaturated stone (dark toned aqua is another example), makes no sense to me.
TL, maybe because many clients find the color very pretty, and as is a testament on PS, finding the right one, especially hard to find, is really tough!
Supply and demand, is my guess!
tourmaline_lover said:I'm afraid if I found the right one, for me that is, it wouldn't be considered a padparadscha!! LOL!